This version was translated from Portuguese by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.
Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar · Eating disorders
Why does obesity persist from one generation to the next? Paula Antonelli Penteado brings together the transgenerational approach (invisible loyalties, vertical stressors), the psychoanalysis of the psychic envelope and of holding, and a social reading of the cult of thinness. She sees the family both as a place where the symptom is transmitted and as an indispensable part of treatment.
Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of Transtornos Alimentares: Transmissão Geracional, Obesidade e Família, by Paula Antonelli Penteado, published in the Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (ABRATEF), vol. 8, no. 1 (2019), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v8i1.44, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Brazilian Portuguese text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. Paragraphs and the heading are those of the journal; the author’s biographical note, printed as a footnote on the first page, is included in the presentation, and the remaining note is renumbered; the quotations from Freud and from Winnicott (p. 403) are given in their published English versions (Standard Edition; “Primary Maternal Preoccupation”), while those from Lacan, Canguilhem, Lipovetsky, Winnicott (p. 25), Fontes and Féres-Carneiro are translated from the article’s Portuguese; a few typographical errors, notably in the names of Vecchiatti and Kaës, have been corrected silently. The abstract is the author’s own English version. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.
It is very hard to imagine changes taking place in the treatment and care of eating disorders without the family’s participation.
Paula Antonelli Penteado
Abstract
The presented article brings questions over obesity and its currencies and maintenance in family’s relations. The eating disorders have a multifactorial etiology, are determinate from complex diversity factors producing and perpetuating a favorable environment for developing those psychopathologies conditions. Besides the lack of the specific literature about eating disorders and affective bond families, this article treats about the obesity in the family. Our focus is the context of family relation in obesity maintenance and abusive family relations.
Keywords: Obesity; family; psych transmission.
According to the World Health Organization, the prevalence of obesity has tripled worldwide since 1975 (WHO, 2015). For Coradini, Moré and Scherer (2017), obesity is a phenomenon that has been emerging as one of the most significant epidemics of the twenty-first century. In their words, “obesity is characterized as an abnormal or excessive accumulation of fat that may be harmful to health” (Coradini, Moré and Scherer, 2017, p. 18). Besides the changes in the population’s eating routines and lifestyle habits – which are held responsible for weight gain – other factors may contribute to its occurrence, such as relational and family factors. If we take into account the exponential increase in cases of eating disorders, as Coradini, Moré and Scherer (2017) point out, we may consider the emergence of a new way of expressing what we feel through these illnesses.
For Morgan, Vecchiatti and Negrão (2002), obesity, anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa are conditions that involve not only disturbances or disorders in the act of eating, but also bodily changes and alterations in self-image, and are therefore categorized as eating disorders. It is important to stress that eating disorders have a multifactorial etiology, that is, they are determined by a variety of factors that interact with one another in complex ways, producing and perpetuating these conditions. Risk factors include comorbidity with other psychiatric disorders, a family history of psychiatric disorders, sexual or physical abuse, and adversity in childhood (Morgan, Vecchiatti, Negrão, 2002).
The first epidemiological studies point to the prevalence of eating disorders among young white women from the more privileged social strata of Western industrialized societies (Fernandes, 2012). They also indicate that certain occupational groups, such as models, ballet dancers, nutritionists and actresses, seem more vulnerable to eating disorders. The author further notes that anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa are thought to be associated with the extreme valuing of thinness as a standard of female beauty in Western societies.
The predisposing factors of eating disorders fall into three groups: individual, familial/hereditary and sociocultural. The individual factor refers to personality traits combined with psychiatric disorders. Familial/hereditary factors involve intrafamilial transmission mechanisms, mixed with biological inheritances/transmissions such as genetic inheritance, as well as those derived from relational patterns of family interaction, whose roots lie in the history of the members of the same family and in the mechanisms of transgenerational family narrative construction. Genetic factors matter, but patterns of family interaction can be very powerful in the transmission of eating disorders. Finally, sociocultural factors are socially shared values and conceptions that build and sustain today’s ideal of beauty centered on thinness, according to which having a thin body is understood as a sign of success and self-control. In this sense, sociocultural factors are decisive in the rise in cases of eating disorders.
For Coradini (2017), the main family factors that influence the transmission of obesity across generations, and that show the variety of aspects and elements present in the development of obesity in the family, are: the environment, eating habits, hereditary character, and family loyalties and beliefs.
According to Carter and McGoldrick (1995), life-cycle stressors can be classified as horizontal or vertical. Horizontal stressors refer to the events that occur throughout individual and family development, marked by the changes and transitional phases of each stage of the life cycle. Vertical stressors, in turn, are characterized by the myths, stories, loyalties, beliefs and patterns present in the family, which are perpetuated from generation to generation and make up what family studies call transgenerationality. It follows that the field of study of obesity in the family context lies at the intersection of horizontal and vertical stressors, since eating, relational and lifestyle patterns, integrated transgenerationally, contribute to the onset, development and maintenance of the illness (Rolland, 1995).
Among the aspects present in transgenerational family dynamics, loyalties and the set of values and beliefs shared by the family are fundamental elements of generational family transmission.
Loyalties concern the expectations that each member holds toward the others; their main constituent elements are the commitment, merit and trust placed within the family group, which are passed on to the following generations (Boszormenyi-Nagy & Spark, 2003).
All these components fit together in an integrated way that is sometimes invisible to most members, so that the transmission of obesity, for instance, takes on a transgenerational character.
When we speak of family, what automatically comes to mind is today’s configuration, based on a patriarchal conception of the last century. Yet as we deepen our studies, we can see that this model inhabiting our imagination has not always been – and is not always – the reality of Brazilian families. The mother-father-children configuration seems to belong more to the realm of ideals, or to the reality of the urban middle classes, than to the general configuration of the population.
Ariès (1978) notes that in Western culture a family is specifically defined as a group of people of the same blood, or legally united by marriage or adoption. Many ethnologists argue that the notion of “blood” as an element of family unification should be understood metaphorically, and that in many societies with non-Western cultures the family is defined by notions other than “blood.” The family could thus be constituted as an institution regulated by a series of rules of affiliation and alliance (Ariès, 1978).
For Lacan (1984), the family is characterized as a group of individuals with a twofold biological relationship: generation, and the conditions of the environment in which the group develops. The human species is characterized by a unique development of social relations. This development is sustained by exceptional capacities for communication and by adaptive behaviors of infinite variety, whose perpetuation and progress forge the culture of the group.
The family’s modes of organization are built through the laws of its transmission, the notions of descent and kinship, and the laws of inheritance and succession, among others, which establish the human family as an institution (Lacan, 1984).
Among all human groups, according to the author, the family plays a primordial role in the transmission of culture. Spiritual traditions, the maintenance of rites and customs, and the preservation of techniques and heritage are what mark this transmission. “The family prevails in early education, in the repression of instincts, in the acquisition of the language rightly called the mother tongue” (Lacan, 1984, p. 9).
For Cerveny (1997), we can only think of the life cycle in association with development, growth, movement, ordering and so on. If the concept of cycle is understood as a sequence of phenomena succeeding one another at a certain rhythm, the author’s description comes close to the life process of the human being, as well as to that of the family life cycle.
The changes the family has undergone over time have not shaken the structure of the family institution; only its patterns have changed. Human beings go on forming associations and relating intimately to one another.
According to Freire (2011), history is very important for understanding current social, political and economic phenomena. Reflecting on eating disorders through history shows the importance of the body and of food for human beings, and helps us understand disordered ways of eating. The colonial past extols fatness as a representation of beauty, status and prosperity. Yet fat loses its prestige, and the many excesses that mark the turn from the twentieth to the twenty-first century contribute to giving new meaning to the concepts of beauty and aesthetics.
Obesity can be viewed broadly and from many angles. Many components mark a maintenance of obesity, but few explain that maintenance. What, then, would explain it?
We know how important genetic factors are in obesity, but the scope of this work is to take up the discussion from the standpoint of the psychosocial determinants that bear on families. We will therefore give priority to the familial, social and cultural perspective.
“The identity of the normal and the pathological is asserted for the benefit of knowledge of the normal” (Canguilhem, 2006, p. 14). What is considered normal and what is considered ill in our society today? Our capacities to act and to relate to the environment in which we live depend on the social environment in which we were raised. From this point we can question our attitudes through attitudes that are or are not appropriate to the context. Thinking along these lines, when and how do we need to define conceptually the boundary between the normal and the pathological? When do doubtful situations call for clarity about the criteria we should use to make this distinction? Bezerra Jr. (2006) asks whether behaviors are a matter of pathology or of difference. Is the normal what is frequent?
Biological norms are not negotiable; they belong to life. Social norms, on the other hand, are negotiable: their values are contingent on each form of social organization and on its time.
According to Bezerra Jr. (2006), in what is called the “risk society,” it is the very idea of a boundary marking off a field of health and a field of pathology that is becoming blurred.
The hallmark of the cult of the body, according to Costa (2005), is not the greater amount of time the subject devotes to the physical, but the particular relationship between psychological-moral life and physical life.
The author also argues that there is a bodily turn, that is, a primacy of the body as a central locus in the construction of identities, which is being conditioned by factors such as the cognitive remapping of the physical body and the invasion of culture by the morality of spectacle; the first phenomenon offers the rational justifications for redescribing what we are, while the second offers the moral norms of what we should be (Costa, 2005).
In the context of today’s society, which we may call lipophobic – one that places a negative value on fat and on fuller body shapes – bulimia nervosa appears as something far from the idea of self-control and much closer to the idea of loss of control, primary need and unmanaged impulse. Still from the perspective of the lipophobic society, anorexia nervosa is almost a rewarded behavior, whereas, by contrast, bulimia nervosa and morbid obesity are disorders marked by the stigma of loss of control, something rejected by a society that rewards limitless production and efficiency.
The stigma of obesity and the meaning attributed to bodies that depart from the ideal of the spectacularized body are also shaped by biases, such as those of gender and class. The social demand to conform to the ideal of the body as spectacle weighs more heavily on women than on men. Something similar happens across the different social strata.
The food choices of members of the classes higher up the social hierarchy are directed toward “healthier” and “lighter” foods that do not cause weight gain, with the aim of staying thin or losing weight. Boltanski (2004) stresses that the valuing of “thinness” grows at the same time as attention to physical appearance develops, and Lipovetsky (2015) observes: “Everywhere, the aim is to expel fat, to make bodies fluid, to relieve them of the weight of corporeality. The hypermodern era sees the triumph of a trans-aesthetic culture of lightness, bearer of airy pleasures and of dreams, but also of nightmares. While the symbolic victory of the light over the heavy is being affirmed, the obsession with health and the tyranny of ‘thinness’ grow, sources of a new weight. This is the irony of the lightness of hypermodern times” (Lipovetsky, 2015, p. 77).
According to Ortega and Zorzanelli (2010), history shows the body of the individual and its basic processes being taken over as a focus of political action and attention. Bodies trained and precise, to produce a disciplinary power over the individual, whatever position that individual holds, whether at school, in the factory or elsewhere. Biopower, a term coined by Foucault in the twentieth century (Ortega and Zorzanelli, 2010, p. 71) to refer to the practice of modern states and their power of regulation over those subject to them, runs through the body and encompasses the life of the species and population phenomena. Power was exercised by creating ways of relating to oneself and to the world, delimiting territory and active production. Foucault places biopower as the vector through which biopolitics is exercised, emerging in the mid-eighteenth century with the consolidation of modern states.
Even sexuality was, and still is, controlled. Sex for reproduction was accepted and encouraged. On the other hand, there appears a control of sexuality in which, for example, homosexuality begins to be seen as something unproductive. Sex that was not for reproduction had to be controlled. In this context, the idea of the population’s health falls to the state, as an instrument for improving the subject and as a guarantee of social well-being, in which the subject is constituted through practices built from accepted and encouraged social relations.
These relational practices remain marked to this day. The social is formed by our practices, which in turn are built and influenced by the environment we live in. Hence the establishment of pathologies consistent with the present time, which imposes the perception that we must somehow belong to this environment.
Looking at adolescence, we can consider belonging in relation to the number and diversity of identity groups that claim social recognition on the internet. These groups allow their members to speak freely and make their thoughts and feelings public. This openness gives people room to express themselves freely and to be welcomed in every way, but we also notice that the way this number and diversity of virtual groups presents itself, spreads ideas and recruits people facilitates the resulting perception that turns something pathological into something normal. In other words, regardless of the period, we are always producing new boundaries and loosening others when it comes to marking the line between health and illness, and between the normal and the non-normal.
The definition of obesity, according to Halpern and Mancini (2002), identifies the environment, genetics and racial factors as influences on weight gain. It is a situation in which a given person has a greater amount of body fat than is considered normal.
If obesity can be categorized as a chronic disease, it involves inadequate or unhealthy eating habits combined with a sedentary life with no physical activity at all. It should be noted that endogenous obesities – related to neuroendocrine factors – may result from a primary organic disorder, such as complex syndromes caused by genetic alterations or endocrine problems, among others; in these cases, changing lifestyle habits has very little effect on reducing them. Exogenous obesities, by contrast, involve external, socio-environmental factors.
Although our focus is on the maintenance of obesity at the heart of the family, which is a specific angle, obesity at the population level cannot be attributed solely to genetics and to family symptoms. This population-wide increase has more to do with economic factors and with political decisions about food production and consumption.
Considering the multifactorial etiology of obesity, we can highlight it as an effect of modes of food production and consumption, linking it to an economic framework. According to the documentary Globesity (2018), the effect of globalization on social and economic dimensions is directly responsible for the substantial increase in obesity in the population.
Among the myths surrounding obesity, we can stress that it is not true that all people with obesity have particular traits that make them gain weight, or that there is a personality specific to people with obesity; at the same time, it is a fact that being obese has emotional consequences (given that obesity is a target of stigma and an object of social oppression – people with obesity are often humiliated, demoralized or shamed), which lead the person to develop certain character traits that are a consequence rather than a cause of obesity, such as lack of confidence, a desire to please, body shame or sexual problems. And there are also people who gain weight because of emotional problems, that is, because of certain emotional situations that lead them to become obese. But not every person with obesity has emotional problems that led to the weight gain. For all these reasons, we can state that obesity is a multifactorial disease.
Family and society are interrelated. Bourdieu (1989) stresses that habitus is acquired knowledge, a capital, like tendencies that organize the ways in which individuals perceive and react to the world around them – with regard to social class, profession, religion, nationality, ethnicity and so on. Habitus therefore represents the way the individual is shaped by culture and personal history within the social world they inhabit, and it can also be seen as a set that unites and/or separates people, forms of consumption, choices and practices into groups.
Setton (2002) conceives of habitus as a conceptual tool that helps us think about the relationship between external social conditioning and the subjectivation of the subject. It is a notion that helps us think about the characteristics of a social identity, a kind of cultural matrix for thinking about the process through which social identities are constituted. On the importance of this sociocultural matrix, psychoanalytic theory also makes contributions. As Freud puts it: “In the individual’s mental life someone else is invariably involved, as a model, as an object, as a helper, as an opponent; and so from the very first individual psychology, in this extended but entirely justifiable sense of the words, is at the same time social psychology as well” (Freud, 1921, p. 91).
If we are a construction of our environment, which includes the family, the process of differentiating ourselves from our matrices can be painful and at times impossible. There is a tendency to “stick” to our families and to make ourselves the same as them, through first name, surname, biological and genetic inheritance, and also through family legacies laden with information.
Family rules exist and are indispensable for teaching members how to establish relationships with one another, how to express their emotions, what is allowed and what is forbidden, how to pass on the family’s legacy to the next members – in short, how to belong to the family group.
Conscious psychic transmission takes place through language and affect, and unconscious transmission takes place through the relationship between subjects belonging to the same group. Differentiation from the group may be greater or lesser and will depend on the process through which the subject’s subjectivity is constructed.
If we think about eating disorders, we can see that the subject’s relationship with food goes through the mouth, precisely the place where all the initial unconscious marks will be revisited through orality.
For Otto and Ribeiro (2012), the association between food and affect is an important aspect to consider in the onset and maintenance of obesity in the family. Moreover, eating is also associated with socialization, which is why the act of eating, whether as routine or socially, is a special moment for some individuals. This moment may be reflected in the behavior of some people who, when they feel lonely or miss pleasurable moments they have lived, seek a form of compensation in food, which may trigger uncontrolled weight gain.
Otto and Ribeiro (2012) also hold that the family is one of the most privileged means of transmission: transmission of life itself, of a name, of a surname, of property, of education, of culture, of a profession, and even of a pathology. The process of transmission in the family is fundamental to the construction of the self, that is, to the formation of the individual’s identity. The family’s generations pass on contents intended to ensure the survival of the family group over time.
The process of transmission and the existence of a new being begin long before the child is conceived. This process occurs when the thoughts, feelings, desires and fantasies of the mother and of the family begin to prepare the place of the child who is to exist. In other words, even before being born, the individual receives a family project and comes into the world embedded in a history (Otto and Ribeiro, 2012).
Generational transmission becomes evident through the repetition of family patterns, and it is in this transmission that the family’s survival and perpetuation reside.
The older generations, in passing on family values and myths, delegate to the members of the family system a role and a destiny, assigned by the family’s laws. According to Boszormenyi-Nagy and Spark (2003), each family has its own laws, which are inherited throughout the family life cycle. Boszormenyi-Nagy and Spark call these contents “invisible loyalties,” because they run through the generations, often without being named explicitly.
The concept of loyalty, for Boszormenyi-Nagy and Spark (2003), can be defined in moral, political and psychological terms. Conventionally, it has been defined as a reliable and positive attitude of individuals. On the other hand, the concept of a web of loyalty among many people or within a group implies the existence of structured expectations of that group, in which all its members accept the commitment.
The focus is on loyalty as a group characteristic and on the personal identities that belong to and shape the group. We can consider that, according to Boszormenyi-Nagy and Spark, to be a loyal member of a group called a family, we have to internalize its expectations and adopt a series of attitudes in order to be in keeping with the group we belong to. However, the needs of a group often do not match individual needs. Differentiation from the group aims to build and maintain individuality without ceasing to belong to the reference group. Building individuality can create conflicts with the transmission of notions of family loyalty. These possible clashes mark the subject’s growth and development throughout life, in the process of building an identity within the family. It is not an easy process, but it is necessary for building the subject’s identity.
Schenker (2008) points out that the process of identification is organized within the family through the socialization that takes place in childhood, mediated by the significant people in the family in their interaction with the social world, and that it is from there that the subject becomes a member of society.
Family values are acquired through education and through the transmission of the values established in the family.
For Puget (2000), there is not only the reality forged by unconscious fantasies and by drive life; there also arises another reality, forged in each encounter between two or more subjects, which leads to the recognition of new elements. The author adds that a further complexity stems from the attempt to understand how subjects build their belonging to a structure on the basis of values that mark their position within a space.
Kaës (2001) stresses that the nodal points of the question of psychic transmission lie in the psychic place that is led to think of itself as the subject both of an inheritance and of the deviation it introduces into what it receives from its parents. The origin is what escapes us, that from which we are absent and which lies beyond our control in the very movement through which we are constituted in and by the desire of the other and, even more, of an other who precedes us. The outcome of the inheritance received and of the process of individualization is the formation of the singular individual, who nevertheless belongs to a group.
Kaës further argues that psychic transmission along the axis of intergenerational relations implies that the subject is apprehended by more than one other. The subject of the group is constituted as a subject of the unconscious, according to the workings of the unconscious itself in intrapsychic space and to the demand for psychic work imposed on the psyche by its link with the intersubjective, by its subordination to the ensembles from which the subject proceeds – family, groups, institutions, masses.
The group that precedes us, for Kaës (2001), supports us and holds us within a matrix of investments and care, predisposing signs of recognition and appeal, assigning places, presenting objects, offering means of protection and attack, tracing paths of fulfillment, indicating limits and stating prohibitions. It is within this ensemble that receives, names, dreamed, invests, situates and speaks the subject of the group that this subject becomes a speaking subject and a spoken subject, not only through the effect of language but through the effect of the desire of those who, like the mother, also act as spokespersons for the desire, the prohibitions and the representations of the ensemble.
Kaës stresses that there is no human psyche unless these psychic actions take place, and that only under these conditions can the subject use the language and speech of the generations that precede them, the signifying predispositions they inherit and partly appropriate for their own purposes.
The subject of the group is not the subject of a single group; several psychic and intersubjective spaces coexist within them, whose formations and processes are transmitted to them psychically (Kaës, 2001) and which they inherit in various ways, through anaclisis, identification and incorporation, with their own demands and their constraints of repression.
Anzieu (1989) uses the term “psychic envelope” for the synthesis of the construction of the self in which, in order to be born psychically, the human baby needs to be assured of its body ego, which consists of its experience of physical containment, of its body being contained, without leaks. Fontes (2017) reports that this containment results from bodily demands that involve contact. And it is not restricted to physical contact alone. It is not only the skin that does this. We are speaking of the gaze, of the surroundings, of care. “The skin envelops the body; by analogy with the skin, the ego envelops the psyche; by analogy with the ego, thinking envelops thoughts” (Fontes, 2017, p. 53).
Anzieu (1984) further notes that the notion of the group envelope understands the group as a “living envelope,” comparing it to the skin that regenerates on the body, close to the Ego that seeks to contain the psyche and is a double-sided membrane. It forms a boundary with the outside and acts as a filter. “The Skin-ego creates the possibility of thinking” (Anzieu, 1989, p. 45).
Fontes (2017) notes that the crucial moment of psychic birth depends on the necessary conditions for the constitution of the subject being in place. Without a bodily-psychic envelope, the subject may appropriate an envelope of fat – in obesity – or a muscular shell – in vigorexia – and thus secures a prosthesis for a psychic skin not previously acquired. In other words, when the contour has not been sufficiently provided in early formation, the subject may use various accessories to contain or delimit their surroundings, including their own body.
For Fontes (2017), ordinary symbiosis does not merely involve melting into the mother, but a continuous, difficult and irreplaceable process for the construction of a body ego. “One must therefore speak of a ‘psychic gestation’ in order for there to be a ‘psychic birth’” (Fontes, 2017, p. 22).
Psychic birth, for the author, consists in the baby gradually acquiring a first sense of existing, reaching an awareness of physical separation from the mother, of there being two beings and not just one. “To constitute a body ego, one must have lived an initial experience that guarantees the continuity of existing” (Fontes, 2017, p. 23).
The author discusses these artificial envelopes, which tend to wear out because of their inability to contain. At first they produce enveloping forms of sensation; subsequently they prove insufficient, requiring more doses of substitute contours. In the attempt to contain or delimit the surroundings, the “layers” of fat or muscle try to make up for the missing psychic envelope as an artificial aid. Fernandes (2006), for her part, describes the formation of a body ego as “a work of reconstruction, or even of construction of meanings.”
In early formation, we can stress that the child develops within the family. Winnicott (1990) describes how, when the child reaches the stage of development at which they can perceive the existence of three people, themselves and two others, they find in most cultures a family structure waiting for them. Within the family, the child can advance step by step from the relationship among three people to others that are more and more complex. It is the simple triangle that presents the difficulties, and also the full richness, of human experience. In the family structure the parents provide continuity in time, perhaps a continuity from the child’s conception to the end of the dependence that marks the close of adolescence.
“Even if, when healthy, the adult continues to grow, develop and change until the moment of death, there is a constant already visible in the child that persists to the end, just as a person’s face remains recognizable throughout their whole life” (Winnicott, 2000, p. 25).
Winnicott (2000) refers to the capacity of mothers1 to devote to their children all the attention they need, meeting their needs for feeding, hygiene and soothing, or through simple contact; this creates the conditions for a feeling of unity between two people to arise. From the healthy relationship between mother and baby emerge the foundations of the constitution of the person and of the child’s emotional and affective development. The mother’s capacity to identify with her child enables her to fulfill the function Winnicott summed up in the term holding. It is the basis for what gradually becomes a being who experiences itself.
The function of holding, in psychological terms, is to provide ego support, particularly in the phase of absolute dependence before the ego has become integrated. Holding mainly includes physically holding the baby, which is a form of loving, of cuddling. However, it also extends to include the total environmental provision prior to the concept of living with, that is, prior to the emergence of the baby as a separate person relating to other people separate from it.
Winnicott (1958) states that every human being has an innate potential to mature and to become integrated; however, the fact that this tendency is innate does not guarantee that it will actually come about, since that depends on a facilitating environment that provides good-enough care, and at the beginning this environment is represented by the mother. It is important to stress that such care depends on each child’s needs, since each human being will respond to the environment in their own way, presenting different conditions, potentials and difficulties at each moment.
If the processes of identity construction and individualization are complex, we can assume that in situations of eating disorders they become much more delicate. For Fernandes (2006), because of the need for interaction with the environment and the dependence of people with eating disorders, family patterns act to maintain the psychopathological picture, and may either help or sustain a condition.
“If the mother provides a good enough adaptation to need, the infant’s own line of life is disturbed very little by reactions to impingement. (Naturally, it is the reactions to impingement that count, not the impingements themselves.)” (Winnicott, 2000, p. 403).
“The family that psychically nourishes the subject from birth and even before gestation, preparing a symbolic place to receive and desire the subject, is the same family whose mission is to launch the subject into the world so that their history, their legacy, may germinate” (Féres-Carneiro, 2007, p. 341).
The range of aspects involved in the etiology of eating disorders is enormous, and the challenge for those who work with these disorders is to understand how various factors interact in each case, and that eating disorders do not emerge abruptly but develop over many years, from predispositions present since the individual’s birth, and continue throughout their history as events unfold.
It is very hard to imagine changes taking place in the treatment and care of eating disorders without the family’s participation. We have spoken at length about how the family contributes to the formation, onset and maintenance of the illness, which is why it is important to stress that this same family is an indispensable part of the treatment of eating disorders.
This same family space forms the emotional basis of the individual’s earliest affects. It is in this environment that the person will live and feel their good and bad affects, as well as their relationship with food, which lies at the center of this experience and marks their future relationships. We receive our share of the family inheritance and must keep this legacy in order to belong to the family; but when we begin to discover new stories and to choose what we identify with most, the struggle begins. Conflicts arise in the transition of the subject’s differentiation and formation, when the subject begins to make choices different from those of their group of origin. The family does not want a different element and does everything to maintain the homeostasis of the system, while the subject wants to differentiate in order to become established as an individual subject. Generational transmission is part of the process together with individual differentiation, making the construction of the subject a long and complex path.
We can reflect on the importance of always keeping a watchful eye on prejudice and on how we take part in it, actively or passively, but always taking part. We transfer this prejudice onto people with excess fat, and we see how uncomfortable this is in today’s society, which prizes beauty, thinness and youth.
For Fernandes (2006), in the context of the social understanding of thinness and fatness – the stereotypes of the social imaginary – weight loss can be seen as a victory, an achievement, as if it endorsed the virtue of one’s methods and self-discipline. Weight gain, by contrast, is taken as a defeat of self-control. As if control over food – not eating or eating selectively – marked command over one’s own life, and eating excessively or lack of control signaled the absence of such command in every area of life. Loss of control and lack of direction.
The discomfort some people may feel when they see a fat person reflects frustrations, desires and fantasies. When we are outside a standard, one built by ourselves, we unsettle the other. The aggressive increase in bariatric surgery and in cases of anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa may indicate a reactive way of dealing with the obesity epidemic, which is advancing by leaps and bounds.
I think of food as a vital necessity, and I wonder how it can turn into something more important than fuel for the body. We can associate food directly with pleasure. Eating is pleasurable and is a form of affection; however, where there is excess, in the sense of compensatory processes in which food compensates for and replaces affection, it can result in the excesses seen in the body. In this sense, where there is excess, there is a problem. Today we are constantly confronted with this question of a general excess of pressure and demand. How do we receive what we have inherited psychically, and how do we constitute ourselves as subjects with an individualized identity within this initial family group, and later within the social group in which we live? The art of selecting and keeping what we have inherited, together with the new things we will discover and assimilate throughout life in the process of building our individualization, brings conflicts and achievements.
Complexe Systémique: key points
The article is more an essay than a study: it gathers heterogeneous references around obesity, from Boszormenyi-Nagy to Lacan, Bourdieu, Kaës, Anzieu and Winnicott, without data or clinical cases. Its value lies elsewhere. It refuses to reduce obesity to genetics or willpower and places it at the intersection of vertical stressors (transmitted loyalties, myths and beliefs) and horizontal ones (life-cycle transitions), without forgetting the weight of the food economy and of stigma. The image of an “envelope of fat” standing in for a missing psychic envelope can open up conversations, provided it does not become an interpretation imposed on people who are already heavily exposed to judgment. Some caution is also needed about the idea of a family that “cooperates” with the illness: the conclusion, which makes that same family an indispensable part of treatment, is more fruitful. In sessions, one question can help: in this family, what is said about the body, food and affection, and what would it cost each member to eat differently? Read alongside the article on the meaning of the symptom in eating disorders, and the article on invisible loyalties.
Notes from the original
1 In this text, “mother” refers to the maternal function.
References
Anzieu, D. (1989). O Eu-pele. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 1989.
Anzieu, D. (1984). O grupo e o inconsciente: o imaginário grupal. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 1993.
Ariès, P. (1978). História social da criança e da família. Rio de Janeiro: LTC Editora, 1978.
Bezerra jr., B. (2006). O normal e o patológico: Uma discussão atual. In A. N. Souza; & J. Pitanguy (Orgs.), Saúde, corpo e sociedade. Rio de Janeiro: Ed. UFRJ, 2006.
Boltanski, L. (2004). As classes sociais e o corpo. São Paulo: Paz e Terra, 2004.
Boszormenyi-nagy, I. & Spark, G. M. (2003). Lealtades Invisibles: Reciprocidad en terapia familiar intergeneracional. Buenos Aires: Amorrortu.
Bourdieu, P. (1989). O poder simbólico. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Bertrand Brasil, 1989.
Canguilhem, G. (2006). O normal e o patológico. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Forense Universitária, 2006
Carter, B. & Mcgoldrick, M. (1995). As mudanças no ciclo de vida familiar: uma estrutura para terapia familiar (2a ed.). Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas.
Cerveny, C. M. O. (1997). Ciclo vital. In: Cerveny, C. M. O. e Berthoud, C. M. E. B. (orgs.). Família e ciclo vital. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 1997.
Coradini, A. O.; Moré, C. L. O. O.; Scherer, A. D. (2017). Obesidade, família e transgeracionalidade: uma revisão integrativa da literatura. In: revista Nova Perspectiva Sistêmica, n. 58, p. 17-37, agosto 2017.
Coradini, A. O. Transgeracionalidade e dinâmica familiar na perspectiva de mulheres com obesidade mórbida. 2017. Dissertação de Mestrado em Psicologia – Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, SC.
Costa, J. F., (1944). O vestígio e a aura: corpo e consumismo na moral do espetáculo. Rio de Janeiro: Garamond, 2005
Féres-Carneiro, T. (2007). Família e casal. Saúde, trabalho e modos de vinculação. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 2007.
Fernandes, M. H. (2006). Transtornos Alimentares: clínica psicanalítica. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 2012.
Fontes, I. (2017). A descoberta de si mesmo: na visão da psicanálise do sensível. São Paulo: Ideias & Letras, 2017.
Freire, D. de S. (2011). Com açúcar, sem afeto. In. DEL PRIORI, Mary; AMANTINO, Marcia. (Orgs.). História do corpo no Brasil. São Paulo: Editora Unesp, 2011.
Freud, S. (1921). Psicologia das massas e análise do ego. In: Obras completas (ESB). Rio de Janeiro: Imago, 1976.
Globesity – Fat’s New Frontier – Documentary Film. 2018. 59 min, son., color. Disponível em: https://topdocumentaryfilms.com/globesity-fats-new-frontier/. Acesso em: 16 março de 2019.
Halpern, A., Mancini, M. C. (2002). Manual de obesidade para o clínico. São Paulo: Roca, 2002.
Kaës, R. Introdução: O sujeito da herança. In: KAËS, René et al. Transmissão da vida psíquica entre gerações. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo, 2001.
Lacan, J. (1984). Os complexos familiares. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar, 2008.
Lipovetsky, G. (2015). Da leveza: rumo a uma civilização sem peso. Barueri, SP: Manole, 2016.
Morgan, C. M.; Vecchiatti, I. R.; Negrão, A. B. (2002). Etiologia dos transtornos alimentares: aspectos biológicos, psicológicos e socioculturais. In Revista brasileira de psiquiatria 2002; 24 (Supl III): 18-23.
Organização Mundial da Saúde – OMS. (2015). Nota descritiva n° 311: Obesidad y Sobrepeso. Disponível em: https://www.who.int/es/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight. Acesso em: 21 de janeiro de 2019.
Ortega, F.; Zorzanelli, R. A saúde como salvação – contexto cultural da ascensão do corpo como valor na contemporaneidade. In Ortega, F.; Zorzanelli, R. Corpo em evidência: a ciência e a redefinição do humano. Rio de Janeiro: Civilização Brasileira, 2010
Otto, A. F. N. & Ribeiro, M. A. (2012). Unidos em torno da mesa: a dinâmica familiar na obesidade. Estudos de Psicologia, 17(2), 255-263.
Puget, J. Disso não se fala... Transmissão e memória. In: Correa, O. (Org.). Os avatares da transmissão psíquica geracional. São Paulo: Escuta, 2000. p. 73-87.
Rolland, J. S. (1995). Doença crônica e o ciclo de vida familiar. In: Carter, B. & McGoldrick, M. Eds., (1995). As mudanças no ciclo de vida familiar: uma estrutura para terapia familiar (2a ed., pp 373-392). Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas.
Schenker, M. Valores familiares e uso abusivo de drogas. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Fiocruz, 2008.
Setton, M. G. J. (2002). A teoria do habitus em Pierre Bourdieu: uma leitura contemporânea. Revista Brasileira de educação. N° 20, 2002.
Winnicott, D. W. (1958). Da pediatria à psicanálise. Rio de Janeiro: Imago Ed., 2000.
Winnicott, D. W. Natureza humana. Rio de Janeiro: Imago Editora, 1990.
Unofficial English translation of Transtornos Alimentares: Transmissão Geracional, Obesidade e Família, by Paula Antonelli Penteado, Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, vol. 8, no. 1 (2019), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v8i1.44, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence. Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.
Unofficial English translation of “Transtornos Alimentares: Transmissão Geracional, Obesidade e Família”, published in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (2019) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.
Read the original articleHow to cite this article
Penteado, P. A. (2019). Eating Disorders: Generational Transmissions, Obesity and Family (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/eating-disorders-generational-transmissions-obesity-and-family (Original work published in 2019 in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, v. 8, n. 1 (2019); republished in 2019 by Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, https://revbrasterapiafamiliar.abratef.org.br/revista/article/view/44)
To go further
Comments 0
Log in to join the discussion. Log in