AI-assisted translation

This version was translated from Portuguese by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.

Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar · Ethics

Systemic family constellation: considerations

A practice that calls itself systemic without being so, and scientific without validation, has nonetheless found its way into Brazilian courts. Verônica A. da Motta Cezar-Ferreira examines the family constellation method derived from Bert Hellinger: a directive and deterministic stance, a patriarchal conception of the couple, reported harms, and the responses of the Federal Council of Psychology, the Senate and lawmakers. Against it, she sets out a systemic reading of the family and its conflicts.

Author Verônica A. da Motta Cezar-Ferreira, São Paulo Association of Family Therapy (Associação Paulista de Terapia Familiar), São Paulo (Brazil)First published Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, July 2024Translation Complexe Systémique, unofficial translation

Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of Constelação familiar sistêmica: considerações, by Verônica A. da Motta Cezar-Ferreira, published in the Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (ABRATEF), vol. 12, no. e0524 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.138, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Brazilian Portuguese text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. Paragraphs and headings are those of the journal; long quotations are set as block quotes; end-of-article statements are grouped in the notes. The abstract is the author’s own English version. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.

Family conflicts are neither dissolved nor worked through in a single session, in a linear and deterministic way.

Verônica A. da Motta Cezar-Ferreira

Abstract

The present work aimed to make considerations about the self-styled systemic family constellation as being neither a psychological nor a systemic practice. Arising from the ideas of Bert Hellinger, it has a directive and deterministic stance. It brings a conception of couples based on patriarchal bases and compulsory heterosexuality. It presents itself as scientific, based on the ideas of a single author, without scientific research, methodology, criticism or any other means of producing knowledge, and it exhibits a visible linearity in its application. Scientists include the systemic family constellation in the realm of pseudosciences. It has caused harm to users. Its practice has been used by the judiciary in family court cases.

Keywords: Systemic Family Constellation, Bert Hellinger, Psychology, Judicial Power.

Introduction

Psychology is the science that deals with human behaviour, taking feelings into account, whether at the conscious level or in the investigation of the unconscious, and giving priority to relationships, since the person is a being in relation, interdependent, and no one can be entirely independent, however much one may imagine or wish it. These are perhaps some of the reasons that make psychology a fascinating science.

Psychology is an extremely serious science, and when people say that every lawyer is “a bit” of a psychologist, or that a doctor is “a bit” of a psychologist, what they mean is that both have sensitivity and humanity and act accordingly. But they are not psychologists, just as a layperson is not “a bit” of a doctor simply because they know a few symptoms and a few remedies to relieve them.

Some initiatives are a cause for concern, such as a practice called systemic family constellation.

Systemic family constellation was already practised by psychologists, generally trained in psychodrama, who preserved the foundations of the theory and of the technique; it was applied by qualified professionals to patients in family therapy and restricted to them, with the therapeutic setting and confidentiality preserved, and with care taken that patients reached their own insight without any steering, assertion of certainties or imposition of attitudes, and with satisfactory results, according to the patients themselves.

The self-styled systemic family constellation

In recent years a new practice has emerged. Calling itself systemic family constellation, it began to make its way into society with the promise of quick solutions, which sounded like magical ones.

In psychology, anything that presents itself as magical should be viewed with caution. In the human psyche, conflicts are resolved through working-through based on perceptions and reflections.

This new kind of practice was created by Bert Hellinger and was reportedly introduced into Brazil by a member of the judiciary. It fascinated the profession and gained ground, above all, it seems, through the promise of quick solutions to problems and of shorter proceedings, which are notoriously long.

The point is that legal practitioners, in general, are not psychologists and have no understanding of psychological processes or treatment techniques. They are laypeople, for whom results are what matter.

The practice began to attract the attention of specialists because of the way it operates. Over time, people who had undergone the procedure came forward publicly to complain, and people from various fields of science began to speak out.

This directive and deterministic stance, adopted by a so-called therapeutic practice, is increasingly ravaging the various segments of society and has become a matter of concern as regards the Brazilian judiciary. This is the practice of systemic family constellation.

Arising from the ideas of Bert Hellinger, a religious German therapist with strong patriarchal and deterministic leanings who calls himself systemic, systemic family constellation has produced family misfortunes and thrown off course the healthy development of families in litigation, through the fanaticism of the professionals who adhere to its concepts and beliefs.

Incidentally, according to experienced psychotherapists who attended Hellinger’s course, he did not create a theory; rather, in his books, chiefly in As ordens do amor (Hellinger, 2001), he reports sessions and fits his ideas into them, including a conception of the couple grounded in patriarchal foundations and compulsory heterosexuality.

Without any knowledge of the concepts, values and principles of the best psychology, constellation practitioners subjugate the people they constellate, force them to take sides against their own rights and values, make them value and forgive their tormentors, and turn them into hostages of a system meant to do them justice and protect them. Constellators do not present themselves as holders of a supposed knowledge but, it seems, as holders of knowledge itself, a dogmatic and unquestionable knowledge. They use fragments of psychological practices and interpret excerpts of theories to their own advantage, without contextualizing them.

Foundations

Cezar-Ferreira and Boulos (2018) had already pointed out factors that argued against the use of the practice by the judiciary:

  • Being applied by people with no training in psychology;
  • Breaching the confidentiality of judicial proceedings;
  • Being recommended by the judge in the case to the parties under their jurisdiction;
  • Having as participants individuals who are strangers to the personal and judicial history of the people being constellated and who, merely by becoming emotional, led constellators to make assertions about the transgenerational causes of the conflict presented;
  • The risk of someone suffering a psychotic episode during the procedure;
  • The stigmatization of those who refuse to take part in the practice.

Concerned about the repercussions of applying this technique in the judiciary, the Association of Family and Succession Law (Associação de Direito de Família e das Sucessões, ADFAS), an international body, invited Professors Rosa Macedo and Sueli Marino, both holders of doctorates, to give a presentation on the subject in May 2022. Leading figures from the national legal scene and from psychological expertise attended the meeting.

Rosa Macedo is a pioneer of systemic family therapy in Brazil and has a deep knowledge of the systemic view, and Sueli Marino attended the systemic family constellation course and has studied the subject.

The debates led to the conclusions that Bert Hellinger was charming but did not believe in psychotherapy, only in the resolution of conflicts in a single contact; that his works are not theoretical but contain accounts into which he inserts his ideas; that the practice is not systemic and that the use of the term results from a trivialization of the expression, far removed from its roots; that the practice makes things enormously easy for everyone, brings immense speed and removes guilt; that it violates people’s privacy, and, more seriously, within the judiciary; that it does not preserve the memory of ancestors; that it exposes the third parties involved; and, finally, that a petition should be sent to the court to prohibit judges from proposing the use of systemic family constellation.

The issue became a matter of concern for ADFAS, which, having discussed it since the previous year, set up in July 2022 an interdisciplinary working group of legal practitioners and women psychologists, all of them learned and experienced, devoted specifically to the study of systemic family constellations and their effects, particularly in the Brazilian judiciary.

Marino and Macedo (2018) show that the level of psychology and philosophy is replaced by another, broader one, which could be called religious or spiritual: “In the training of constellators (therapists who work with this technique), the aim is for them to be connected with what [Hellinger] calls the Movement of the Spirit, a field of wisdom that guides us in life, according to Hellinger” (pp. 25–26).

According to these researchers, for so-called systemic family constellation:

The problems a person experiences are called, according to Family Constellation, entanglements, and they indicate some interference in the orders of love (belonging, order and balance).

These entanglements are related to some kind of exclusion, injustice, bereavement, serious illness, broken bonds, adoption, suicide and even quarrels over inheritance. The constellator’s role will be to identify the entanglement and to restore the flow of the orders of love in the family system of the constellee (the person who presents their problem in the constellation group).

The people in the group who are watching the work will be invited by the constellator or by the constellee to act as representatives of the family system and to dramatize situations in which the problem was perceived. The constellator then, on the basis of this perception related to some aspect of the entanglements, directs the enactment and steers the actors’ lines with specific predetermined phrases such as: dear Mummy (or Daddy), please look at me kindly, I acknowledge you, you will always have a place in my heart, I bow to you; and intervenes on the basis of what they perceive from this field of wisdom or movement of the spirit (Marino & Macedo, 2018, p. 26).

Systemic family constellation is taught as a systemic phenomenological technique focused on conflict resolution, but the passage quoted above would suffice to conclude that it is neither psychological nor systemic.

To consider just one facet of the work, the interview, one of the most important stages of any kind of care, psychotherapeutic or not, it is worth recalling that the approach taken to the interview significantly affects the type, form and detail of the information gathered. It also influences who is in control of the process and of the content of data collection: the party being interviewed or the mediator.

There is no initial interview in the systemic family constellation approach. Theoretical and media sources indicate that the technique is simply applied.

A communication professional or a therapist does not decide for people, unlike what is observed in the practice of constellation, where the answers are ready-made and complete.

To be a therapist and deal with interpersonal conflicts, one needs a suitable, critical and ethical mindset, theoretical knowledge and instrumental resources that make it possible to put the work into practice.

The family constellator, from what has been observed, follows, step by step, rigid rules laid down by the method’s originator and, on empirical bases, draws up a picture of family functioning in the form of a closed diagnosis.

Scientists state that there is no scientific control in systemic family constellation.

In June 2022, the Social Affairs Committee of the Federal Senate, chaired by Senator Eduardo Girão, heard a large number of supporters who praised the practice of family constellations. The speeches were emotional, highlighting notions such as the age of energy, the healing of the soul and telepathy, and referring to Allan Kardec and to the insistence on honouring one’s father and mother, which, although commendable, points, in this context, to a biblical commandment.

The few scientists who spoke had been invited by Senator Sérgio Petecão and stated that those arguments do not constitute science and should not be taken up as part of public policy.

We strongly recommend listening to the scientific contributions that regard systemic family constellations as pseudoscience, and we highlight here, by way of illustration, some remarks by Professor Tiago Pires Tatton Ramos, who holds a doctorate and a postdoctorate in Psychology from the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul.

Tatton, declaring himself dismayed, showed that science is not made with opinions; it requires scientific validation in order to be recognized. He explained that scientific validation is important and occurs when research findings are confirmed, after years of well-conducted experimentation and publication in academic journals, and result from hundreds of studies with controlled practice and systematic reviews. Once carried out in large numbers, such research must be approved by an ethics committee. There is also a need for studies on its use in the country where it is applied, in this case Brazil. Only after all this care can a given practice be presented as a safe, effective and efficient option for that particular condition.

The speaker was appalled that systemic family constellation, a practice without scientific validation and with strong hallmarks of pseudoscience, as he put it, is already part of public life and of the judiciary. He stated that public policy is not made with emotional accounts or appeals to emotion, evading the issue and inventing concepts of science. Talking about family constellations and systemic cures sounds irresponsible, unethical and even dangerous. It is good science that serves as the guiding thread of safety.

He further reiterated that systemic family constellation is a practice without scientific validation and that only after years of research establishing the benefits and risks of a given intervention can one speak of a scientific practice. He added that dubious assumptions, such as orders of love, quantum fields, telepathy and intuitions, come nowhere near meeting the criteria of scientific validation. He presented a 2021 review study in which the researchers found four thousand possible studies, of which only nine could claim some kind of supposed benefit, and even these were not controlled designs and did not have adequate comparison groups.

In addition, he stated that in one of the studies 8% of participants experienced negative effects, and one of them had elevated scores of psychopathology, of mental illness, after receiving the family constellation. He said he had learned from other research that changes of this kind can lead to depression and even to a risk of suicide. According to Professor Tiago Tatton, the authors of the study concluded that more studies were needed, given the huge gap between research findings and what adherents claim, especially for the purposes of public policies, which are already in place in health care and in the judiciary.

Tatton also mentioned, at that session of the Federal Senate, the appearance in podcasts, newspapers and other media of accounts by people who felt invaded, invalidated and violated by family constellation, particularly women. He stated categorically that nowhere in the world is this practice part of public policy and that, in terms of science, all that exists today on family constellation is opinion.

On 26 February 2023, Gabriela Bailas submitted to the United Nations (UN) the input entitled “The practice of family constellations’ within the Brazilian justice system as a form of gendered violence against women”, which, once accepted, led the UN to take an interest in receiving information from the Brazilian authorities.

It was for no reasons other than those set out in these considerations that the Federal Council of Psychology (Conselho Federal de Psicologia, CFP) issued Technical Note No. 1/2023 on 3 March 2023, which states:

The purpose of this note is to guide the psychology profession regarding the use of Family Constellation, also called Systemic Family Constellations, with respect to ethical aspects and, consequently, to its use as an adjunct contribution or as a main practice in any context in which psychologists work (Conselho Federal de Psicologia, 2023).

And, in its conclusion, it states:

Finally, the scientific and epistemological inconsistency of Family Constellation, as well as its dissonance with the Code of Professional Ethics of the Psychologist and professional legislation, lead the Federal and Regional Councils of Psychology to conclude that the practice is, at present, incompatible with the exercise of Psychology (Conselho Federal de Psicologia, 2023).

On 30 March 2023, state deputy Andrea Werner, of São Paulo, introduced Bill No. 293/2023, prohibiting the practice of family constellation in the state of São Paulo on the basis of the CFP’s position, stating:

Article 1 – The practice of Family Constellation is prohibited in the public bodies of health, education, social assistance and public administration, as well as in the other, unspecified bodies of the Legislature, the Executive and the Judiciary within the State of São Paulo (Alesp, 2023).

And it says in its justification:

The understanding of family in Family Constellation rests on the naturalization of the biological bond, without considering the historical, social and political aspects that make up families, and has as its theoretical foundation the use of violence as a mechanism for restoring a violated hierarchy, even attributing to girls and women the responsibility for the violence they have suffered. The responsibility to act in the prevention of, response to and punishment of acts of gender-based violence against women is the exclusive duty of the State, which cannot privatize its functions in favour of “domestic” and faith-healing solutions such as those adopted by the practice of Family Constellation (Alesp, 2023).

In July 2023, the Minister of Human Rights and Citizenship, Silvio Almeida, forwarded to the National Human Rights Council a letter signed by scientists calling for a public debate on possible abuses in the practice of family constellation as psychotherapy (Folha de S.Paulo, 2023).

Final considerations

According to Cezar-Ferreira (2017), the family is the matrix of its members’ identity. It results from a co-construction in which the members’ creativity is expressed, limited by the ethics of responsibility and by the creativity of the others. The family can fundamentally be seen as a unit of care, which is also how the law sees it today.

There is no better or worse family in itself. What probably distinguishes one from another is the extent to which they can be functional and affectionate in caring for their members, and have a clear limit of assertiveness and a high limit of affection.

Great caution is needed when caring for a family and its members. The family functions as a system.

Being able to read the family as a system means understanding it as a set of elements that interrelate and exert reciprocal influences to form a single whole. Hence our concern for all members of the family when an event affects any one of them.

To make it easier to understand how the family comes to form this single whole, the following reasoning can be proposed: the family is a psycho-affective unit on which the development of its members depends. In intimacy, it gradually builds a relational pattern that gives unity and identity to itself and to its own. In continuous living together, in its space, family members establish interactions, share language and build patterns of relationship grounded in values, beliefs and myths.

Since the family is a psycho-affective unit, any event, internal or external, that affects it to any degree will affect its members individually, alter that pattern and cause a momentary destructuring, which will require finding a new level of stabilization for each member and for the family as such. New co-constructions are always under way.

Every day, small events affect the pattern of family interaction. It is the large, serious or important events that get noticed, and they can alter not only the structure of the family but also its organization.

Various areas of professional activity are devoted to helping resolve interpersonal conflicts, and all of them, whether aware of it or not, act upon human communication.

Human communication is complex, not only because it includes verbal aspects with codes specific to human beings, languages, which are culturally created, but also because it involves non-verbal aspects, which cannot be discarded or avoided in any interaction. This explanation of communication is merely didactic; to speak of verbal communication and non-verbal communication is a perissology.

Moreover, both verbal and non-verbal aspects, although they are expressed objectively, inevitably convey the subjectivity of the interlocutors. This is a fact worth highlighting because, to get as close as possible to the meaning of a given communication and, in the case of conflicts, to help the parties in conflict give new meaning to its contents and find a new point of balance in the relationship and a healthy channel of communication, the professional must also be an expert in the study and investigation of subjectivity, which implies having means of access to the unconscious aspects that determine communication and the way it presents itself.

The way relationships unfold and the way people behave fulfil a function in the interaction which, before being disregarded, needs to be uncovered. The form of contact is neither casual nor random.

The training of family therapists involves building a critical, reflective attitude, with ethical responsibility and theoretical and methodological support, which results from a long process of building one’s identity as a family therapist.

The law aims to organize life in society. It falls to the judiciary to settle the conflicts that arise between natural and/or legal persons so that balance is restored or a new balance is established in relationships.

The family is viewed with special care by Brazilian law, notably in the Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil (1988) and in infra-constitutional legislation, such as the Statute of the Child and Adolescent (1990) and the Brazilian Civil Code (2002).

Family court conflicts are, in the final analysis, problems that families have which, having found no solution earlier, reach the courthouse as a last resort, so that someone will resolve them. They are no different from the problems that reach family therapy practices; they simply become part of another context and take on a different configuration.

Family conflicts are neither dissolved nor worked through in a single session, in a linear and deterministic way, without scientific grounding, methodology, ethics or scientific criticism, which is how, according to everything researched and set out here, the self-styled systemic family constellation presents itself.

Thus, in view of the robust body of evidence, the matter at hand deserves the utmost caution in its consideration by the judiciary, not least because one must not forget the importance of the judge as an elicitor of change in the judicial system and the strength of the judge’s social function. Systemic therapists of the most varied backgrounds must be wary of revolutionary and innovative proposals lacking the scientific basis to support them.

Complexe Systémique: key points

This article is a position statement rather than a piece of research: it draws on a Senate hearing, institutional documents and a handful of secondary sources, and the 2021 systematic review it mentions is not among its references. Its value for clinical practice lies elsewhere. It is a reminder that “systemic” is not a protected label: a method that prescribes sentences to be spoken, attributes difficulties in advance to transgenerational entanglements and decides on people’s behalf turns its back on the circularity, co-construction and curiosity on which family therapy rests. It also shows what such a practice becomes when the courts propose it: is consent free when the judge is the one recommending it, and what do “honouring” and forgiving mean for a woman who has suffered violence? For therapists, it is an invitation to explain clearly what systemic therapy does, and what it does not do, to families and to the judiciary alike. Read alongside the interview in which Bert Hellinger presents his method, and the reflection on forgiveness and invisible loyalties.

Notes from the original

Conflict of interest. Nothing to declare.

Data availability statement. Not applicable.

Funding. Not applicable.

Acknowledgements. Not applicable.

References

Assembleia Legislativa do Estado de São Paulo (Alesp) (2023). Projeto de Lei nº 293/2023. Alesp. Recuperado de https://www.al.sp.gov.br/spl/2023/03/Propositura/1000485548_1000622831_Propositura.pdf

Bailas, G. (2023). Postagem. Twitter. Recuperado de https://twitter.com/bibibailas/status/1630025809925636097

Brasil (1988). Constituição Federal da República Federativa do Brasil. Senado Federal.

Brasil (1990). Estatuto da Criança e do Adolescente. Lei nº 8.069, promulgada em 1990. Senado Federal.

Brasil (2002). Código Civil Brasileiro. Lei nº 10.406. Senado Federal.

Brasil (2022). Senado Federal. Senado homenageia terapia denominada constelação familiar. Senado Federal. Recuperado de https://www12.senado.leg.br/tv/plenario-e-comissoes/sessao-especial/2022/09/senado-homenageia-terapia-denominada-constelacao-familiar

Cezar-Ferreira, V. A. M. (2017). Família, separação e mediação: uma visão psicojurídica (4ª ed.). CRV.

Cezar-Ferreira, V. A. M., & Boulos, K. (2018). Constelação familiar no judiciário: ponderações. Carta Forense.

Conselho Federal de Psicologia (2023). Nota Técnica nº 1, de 3 de março de 2023. Conselho Federal de Psicologia.

Folha de S.Paulo (2023). Ministro dos DH pede ação contra abuso de técnica da constelação familiar. Folha de S.Paulo. Recuperado de https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/colunas/painel/2023/10/ministro-dos-dh-pede-acao-contra-abuso-de-tecnica-da-constelacao-familiar.shtml

Hellinger, B. (2001). As ordens do amor. Cultrix.

Marino, S., & Macedo, R. (2018). A constelação familiar é sistêmica? Nova Perspectiva Sistêmica, 27(62), 24-33. https://doi.org/10.38034/nps.v27i62.441

Unofficial English translation of Constelação familiar sistêmica: considerações, by Verônica A. da Motta Cezar-Ferreira, Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, vol. 12, no. e0524 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.138, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence. Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.

Unofficial English translation of “Constelação familiar sistêmica: considerações”, published in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (2024) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.

Read the original article

How to cite this article

Cezar-Ferreira, V. A. da M. (2024). Systemic family constellation: considerations (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/systemic-family-constellation-considerations (Original work published in 2024 in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, v. 12, n. e0524 (2024); republished in 2024 by Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, https://revbrasterapiafamiliar.abratef.org.br/revista/article/view/138)

Discussion

Comments 0

Log in to join the discussion. Log in

  1. No comment yet. Start the discussion.

Cart

Your cart is empty.