This version was translated from Portuguese by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.
Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar · Eating disorders
What if anorexia nervosa, which presents itself as extreme mastery of the body, actually signalled a loss of control? Ieda Zamel Dorfman and Mara Lucia Rossato, psychologists and couple and family therapists in Porto Alegre, explore this paradox through two characters in the Mexican film Malos hábitos (Bad Habits, Simón Bross, 2007): a nun who fasts to stop the rain and a mother who polices her daughter’s weight. They draw some pointers for treatment: stay out of power struggles over food, and help the patient find control elsewhere.
Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of A Dinâmica do Controle na Anorexia Nervosa, by Ieda Zamel Dorfman and Mara Lucia Rossato, published in the Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (ABRATEF), vol. 4, no. 1 (2012), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v4i1.69, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Brazilian Portuguese text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. The text was established from the journal’s PDF; paragraphs and headings are those of the journal; the two opening paragraphs on Bruch, omitted by the automatic extraction, have been restored; the authors’ biographical notes, printed as footnotes on the first page, are included in the presentation; Bruch’s book, cited in the article as “The Golden Cage”, is given under its original title, The Golden Cage; the quotations from Haley (cited from the Spanish edition) and Catrina are translated from the Portuguese, not taken from the English originals; a few typographical errors have been corrected silently. The abstract is the authors’ own English version. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.
They try to feel in control of their lives by controlling their bodies. However, this false control shows that they are, in fact, desperately out of control.
Ieda Zamel Dorfman, Mara Lucia Rossato
Abstract
During our clinical experience, we observed that young people already have had some emotional and behavioral alteration a long time before the disease begins. Also we identified, systematically, the presence of the dynamics of the control in every anorexia case that we saw. This reason motivated our interest to study more about this topic. We have checked that the material about this subject was poor, while we were doing a brief literature review about this theme. This way, we have tried to point the understanding about the meaning of the “control” in this disease and in the family. This article deals with the issue of control in eating disorders and nervous anorexia, through the study of some aspects of the film Bad Habits, directed by Simón Bross, 2007, that treats about the relationship of four women whose lives are united not just by family laces, but, mainly, by the eating disorders. We will not deepen about etiology, symptomatology and evolution of the disorder because there is a large literature about this subject. The stories of two of the four characters, Matilde and Elena, are the basis to discuss and illustrate the paradoxical dynamic of control as a way out of control.
Keywords: anorexia; control; family.
Bruch (1978), in her book The Golden Cage, was the first to regard the issue of control as central to anorexia nervosa, when she found that women showed a need to establish control in their lives.
She suggests that, for many women, anorexia represents an act of self-assertion.
Anorexia nervosa is a disorder of eating behaviour in which the relentless pursuit of thinness leads the person to resort to strategies for losing weight. People with anorexia have an intense fear of gaining weight, even when they are extremely thin, which can lead to a distortion of body image. It mainly affects females, adolescents and young adults, in the 12 to 18 age range, although it is also seen in younger children, regardless of social class. Although it is most frequent at around 15 years of age, girls as young as nine and ten have been arriving at consulting rooms with excessive weight loss. The causes of anorexia are traversed by three main ideas, relating to biological, psychological and sociocultural factors (Rutigliano, 2003).
Weight loss is slow but progressive, and the clinical risks can lead to death. It is also associated with a progressive change in behaviour.
There are no statistics on the incidence of anorexia in Brazil, but international data indicate that it may affect up to 20% of adolescent girls of all social classes. Specifically with regard to anorexia nervosa, the number of cases has increased. In the United States it is the third most common chronic illness among adolescents, after obesity and asthma (Fischer et al., in Fiates & Salles, 2001). According to Pinzon and Nogueira (2004), the main causes of mortality are complications of anorexia nervosa itself (50% to 54%), suicide (24% to 27%) and unknown causes (15% to 19%).
The initial symptoms are classic. It is known that, emotionally, these at-risk patients show some constant criticism of some part of their body and dissatisfaction with their weight, and start dieting because they think they are fat, even when their weight is proportionate to their height; and even when they lose weight, they keep on dieting (Nunes et al., 2006). They do not believe it when told they are too thin, and when they eat, they may make themselves vomit or exercise excessively to relieve their guilt.
The ideal to be pursued relentlessly is to be beautiful, young and thin. People in general, and adolescents in particular, tend to believe that models and film and television stars are prototypes to be copied. Aesthetics thus ceases to be a matter of harmony and becomes an imposition.
The preoccupation with weight reflects a need to find in the body a concrete source of self-esteem and control, resulting in an unhealthy relationship with food. This pattern of relating begins in the contact between mother and baby.
Ramos (2008) says that
food has a constant function in our lives: besides allowing our body to function, it serves to facilitate bodily and affective contact, especially in the first stage of our development. Food also binds people together… Breast milk – or formula milk – is our first food. Its purpose is to nourish the body, but it is very important that the mother can give the baby affection and tenderness through breastfeeding. In this contact, the baby will gradually come to recognize its mother, her smell, her gaze, and will even be able to distinguish the beating of her heart. It will have many sensations that allow it to feel good and snug or, on the contrary, rejected. This is how the important mother–baby relationship begins, which, incidentally, is a two-way street, like all relationships (p. 3).
Still according to Ramos (2008), this relationship can sometimes be nourishing in both the physical and the psychological sense, or it can be frustrating and conflictual. The baby can sense the mother’s irritation and even her delay in responding to its demand.
These mothers are unable to decode their child’s demand and quickly offer the breast or the bottle, trying to calm their own anxiety and the baby’s, closing its mouth with milk. Without realizing it, this mother is passing on to the child a pattern of behaviour; she is imprinting a type of relationship with herself and with food.
The father, in these families, generally behaves in an omissive way, does not commit himself to his daughter (or son), and denies the dangers of the illness. He reinforces his distant behaviour and takes no action for fear of having to face criticism from his wife, who comes across as the stronger and more decisive one. The mother is often demanding and critical. It is also not unusual to observe that, long before the anorexia appears, the mother generally shows great concern about her own body image. She has usually been on diets and eating regimes several times in her life.
Bruch (1978) presents as one of the causes of anorexia the neglectful attitudes of a mother who cannot recognize the child’s emotional needs and deprives the child of what would enable self-perception. There would be a deficiency in learning to read the stimuli needed to identify what one’s own body needs.
Dorfman (2003) says that people with anorexia go through various experiences of conflict and psychic suffering over the course of their lives, whether in accepting themselves and their basic needs (e.g., needing food) or in relation to the expectations of other people they seek to meet (e.g., family members). As a result, they use an unhealthy relationship with food as a form of control.
The 2007 Mexican film Bad Habits (Malos hábitos), directed by Simón Bross, deals with the relationship of four women whose lives are bound together not only by family ties but, above all, by eating disorders. Their faith, their love and their vanity are all put to the test at the dinner table. Matilde is a young nun convinced that faith moves mountains. She secretly begins a mystical fast to prevent a flood she believes is coming. Elena is a beautiful, slim woman who is ashamed of her daughter Linda’s weight and intends to do everything she can to make her lose weight before the day of her First Communion. Meanwhile, Linda is ready to defend herself to escape her mother’s pride. At the same time, Gustavo, Linda’s father, rediscovers love in the arms of a student nicknamed Gordinha (“Chubby”), who is equally passionate about food. Bad Habits is the story of women whose eating habits determine and dominate their lives in very extreme ways.
Matilde is a girl from a highly religious family. At the Good Friday dinner, the day Catholics devote to penance through abstaining from meat, Matilde sees her uncle choke on a fish bone. She stops eating and starts praying for him to be saved. When the uncle manages to clear his throat, the girl seems to come to believe in her power to control the outside world. Next we see Matilde graduate in medicine: she hands her diploma to her parents and enters the convent. Here one of the basic characteristics present in most families with an eating disorder seems evident. The girls are generally studious, high achievers and very concerned with meeting their parents’ expectations, which places them in a position of lacking control over their own lives.
For those who cannot express their opinions or needs, controlling food and their body may be the only way to externalize their search for a sense of autonomy (Catrina, 1990).
Matilde’s family reinforces her position of power and control when her mother asks her to save her aunt, who is ill in hospital. The way she finds to meet the family’s expectations once again is an expedient valued in the Catholic Church, fasting, in which salvation is obtained through sacrifice.
Throughout the film, in Matilde’s case, the intensity with which power and control are exercised through food, in order to be deserving of salvation in the face of a situation of powerlessness, is plain to see.
This is also shown when the convent goes through financial difficulties and the solution comes from selling food. Then Matilde begins to watch on television the consequences of the heavy rain that keeps falling on the city, and once again resorts to food restriction in order to make the rain stop. She tries to gain control by punishing herself, following the logic that the greater the suffering, the greater the control she will have over the world.
As Catrina (1990) says, the body is the site of their struggles. Unable to change the world or their real lives, they try to transform their own bodies. However, in giving voice to protest, anorexia cannot change the real conditions for dealing with the internal conflict over control of feelings.
At this point in the film, the progression of Matilde’s illness begins to become clear. The dynamic of feeling pleasure in eating while at the same time feeling guilt appears in the scene in which she eats an apple – a Catholic symbol of sin – and then weeps compulsively, throwing the apple to the floor.
Matilde is hospitalized and fed by drip and tube, because she has been fainting and is anaemic. What stands out here is the paradox of control versus loss of control, which can go as far as putting life at risk, making anorexia the psychiatric illness with the highest mortality rate (Assumpção & Cabral, 2002).
The film ends with Matilde taking off her habit when she sees that the rain will not stop, surrendering to the precariousness of her power and control.
Elena is introduced to the family as Gustavo’s girlfriend at the same Good Friday dinner mentioned above. Her sister-in-law immediately notices that she eats little and remarks: here you’re going to eat well (sic), showing the family’s preoccupation with food. Elena and Gustavo marry, and later their daughter Linda is born weighing more than four kilos, which stirs the mother to a clear expression of displeasure.
As Linda grows up, Elena becomes increasingly preoccupied with her own weight and body, and also controls her daughter’s eating. She develops a relentless pursuit of mastery over her daughter’s eating and weight, seeking out inappropriate professionals and methods and showing an unhealthy attention to the girl’s physical development. This provokes the opposite reaction in the daughter, suggesting that she may develop an eating disorder in the future.
The self-esteem of a person with anorexia is tied to body shape and weight. Thus, losing weight is seen as an achievement, a victory; conversely, gaining weight is felt as a failure and a loss of control.
The initial concern with having a perfect body becomes an obsession with controlling the body, with the feeling that any spontaneous nourishment – which comes naturally from the desire to eat – is experienced as weakness and loss of control. Elena thus intensifies her food restriction, in an attempt to regain control of a life – and a daughter – that seems hard to master. In this way she tries to find a source of power that is missing in other areas of her life. She does not have many social relationships, does not work, and her marriage is in crisis. Her husband is distant, involved with a younger mistress who is overweight.
Haley (1971) states that the symptom provides an advantage with regard to controlling what may happen in the relationship. In the case of anorexia, with regard to what may happen to one’s own body. It imposes great subjective suffering, but, according to him, some people prefer “this suffering to living in a world of social relationships over which they have little control” (p. 18).
Elena’s illness worsens, with hair loss, an exaggerated increase in exercise and greater food restriction, which draws her further and further away from family intimacy and everyday life, as she lives almost exclusively for food and the desire to lose weight. Her life comes to be controlled by the illness, which leads to her death.
Control is related to power. To feel confident and in control of their lives, both characters try to control their bodies. However, this control fails, revealing in fact a total lack of control over life which, paradoxically, exposes them to risk.
The paradoxical dynamics of control in anorexia nervosa seems to become clear. In trying to gain control of their lives or their desires, they obstinately try to restrict their eating, in an exaggerated control of weight and body. Yet the need to establish this precarious control betrays how far out of control and in danger they are.
It is not pathological in itself to want to have control over relationships. Everyone does this in some way. However, doing it and denying it, or carrying on doing it even when at risk, becomes pathological.
We consider it fundamentally important that the professionals involved in treating anorexia nervosa be alert to this paradoxical dynamic of power and control in the genesis of the symptom and in the dynamics of family relationships, so as to choose the most appropriate therapeutic strategies. Knowing that the pain of the symptom is preferred to having no control (Haley, 1971), it is necessary to help the patient establish adequate control over her life, her emotions and her relationships, especially her family relationships, without needing to displace this control onto eating. At the same time, work needs to be done with the family so that it is in tune with this goal, valuing the patient’s competences and knowing how to recognize them.
From the 1950s onwards, the family began to be treated as a unit in psychotherapy, but it was in the 1970s that family psychotherapy became part of the multidisciplinary approach to eating disorders (Cobelo et al., 2004; Falceto et al., 1993).
Studies carried out by the groups of Minuchin and Palazzoli (in Roberto, 2002) show that problems in family relationships may be associated with the onset and maintenance of the eating disorder.
According to Dorfman (2003), families with an eating disorder are characterized by being excessively enmeshed, with difficulty in differentiation and individuation of their members. They are overprotective families, which delays the development of autonomy and competence and the pursuit of interests outside the safety of the family. They are families that deny the difficulties or conflicts among their members and, as a consequence, have difficulty helping them to solve their problems.
Patients bring to therapy negative attitudes and feelings about themselves, of helplessness, and their sense of having lost control over every aspect of their lives. Developing a positive self-image and an increased sense of control are two of the main aims of therapy, that is, a feeling of esteem and control that is not based on body size. The self-esteem of a person with anorexia is tied to body shape and weight. Accordingly, weight loss is seen as an achievement and as self-discipline, while weight gain is regarded as a failure of self-control. As a result, they may become defensive and angry at not having reached their goal, leading to feelings of loneliness and, possibly, depression.
To feel better about themselves, they set off the cycle of control again to achieve their aim. Living becomes a game of control, in the hope of finding relief. They try to feel in control of their lives by controlling their bodies. However, this false control shows that they are, in fact, desperately out of control.
Therapy must be both challenging and safe. Therapists need to recognize that experiences of helplessness and powerlessness are rooted in the lives of people who suffer from anorexia.
For those who cannot express their opinions or needs, controlling food and their body may be the only way to externalize their search for a sense of autonomy. Anorexia thus becomes a kind of veiled protest, as Catrina (1990) says, in which control is related to power. To feel confident and in control of their lives, they try to control their bodies.
For Catrina (1990), “in giving voice to women’s protests, anorexia and bulimia cannot change the real conditions for dealing with the conflict” (p. 1).
Maintaining control over eating and weight is a very important mechanism in the internal conflict over control of feelings. When the therapist does not recognize the issue of control, patients may often not feel understood. Power struggles in therapeutic relationships can become disastrous, forcing patients who feel out of control to cling more desperately to the only control they have: over their own bodies. The more therapists try to take power away from clients with anorexia by controlling them, the more their symptoms or behaviours may increase. It is necessary to understand that symptoms represent the expression of anxieties, fears, anger, guilt or any other feeling that cannot be translated into words and is therefore expressed through the body.
Complexe Systémique: key points
This text is worth reading for a simple, clinically fruitful reversal: anorexia presents itself as an excess of mastery, yet it signals a loss of control, with control over the body standing in for control over relationships in which the person feels powerless. Haley is not far away, with his view of the symptom as a way of regulating the relationship. The practical consequence is valuable: any power struggle over the plate risks strengthening the symptom, and therapy does better to restore control elsewhere, in life, emotions and relationships. Using the film makes the argument vivid, but it rests on two fictional characters rather than clinical data. Above all, the portrait of the demanding mother, the absent father and the enmeshed family draws on older models that current research strongly qualifies: there is no typical “anorexic family” profile, and family-based approaches now treat parents as allies rather than causes. Read alongside the narrative review of the role of family relationships in eating disorders, and the article that rereads anorexia as a project with White and Sartre.
References
Bross, S. (Diretor) (2007). Maus hábitos [Filme]. México: Altavista Filmes.
Bruch, H. (1978). The golden cage: the enigma of anorexia nervosa. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Catrina, B. (1990). The control paradox: understanding and working with anorexia and bulimia. Retirado em 22/12/2011 do National Eating Disorder Information Centre, www.nedic.ca - http://www.nedic.ca/knowthefacts/documents/TheControlParadox.pdf
Cobelo, A. W., Saikali, N. O., & Schoner, E. Z. (2004). A abordagem familiar no tratamento da anorexia e bulimia nervosa. Rev. Psiquiat. Clínica, 31(4), 184-187.
Dorfman, I. Z., Sanchez, P. C., & Jaeger, M. A. (2003). Transtornos alimentares. In A. M. S. Bassols & col. Saúde mental na escola: uma abordagem multidisciplinar. Porto Alegre: Mediação.
Dorfman, I. Z. (2003, maio). Transtornos alimentares. Rainha dos Apóstolos, 944, 44-45.
Falceto, O. (1993). Anorexia nervosa: querem que eu viva? Revista ABP-APAL, 15(1), 11-16.
Fiates, G. M. R., & Salles, R. K. (2001). Fatores de risco para o desenvolvimento de distúrbios alimentares: Um estudo em universitárias. Revista de Nutrição Campinas, 14, 3-6.
Haley, J. (1971). Estrategias en psicoterapia. Barcelona: Toray S.A.
Nunes, M. A., Appolinário, J. C., Galvão, A. L., Coutinho, W., & col. (2006). Transtornos alimentares e obesidade (2. ed.). Porto Alegre: Artmed.
Pinzon, V. & Nogueira, F. C. (2004). Epidemiologia, curso e evolução dos transtornos alimentares. Revista de Psiquiatria Clínica, São Paulo, 31(4), 158-160.
Pinzon, V., Gonzaga, A. P., Cobelo, A., Labaddia, E., Belluzzo, P., & Fleitlich-Bilyk, B. (2004). Peculiaridades do tratamento da anorexia e da bulimia nervosa na adolescência: a experiência do PROTAD. Revista de Psiquiatria Clínica, São Paulo, 31(4), 167-169.
Ramos, M. (2008). Família e anorexia. III Congresso Internacional de Psicopatologia Fundamental e IX Congresso Brasileiro de Psicopatologia Fundamental, retirado em 19/03/2012 de http://www.fundamentalpsychopathology.org/8_cong_anais/MR_344b.pdf
Roberto, L. G. (2002). Transtornos alimentares como segredos de família. In E. Imber-Black e col. Os segredos na família e na terapia familiar (2. ed., pp. 166-182). Porto Alegre: Artmed.
Rutigliano, A. (2003). Anorexia nervosa: an issue of control. Retirado em 19/03/2012 de http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/bb/neuro/neuro03/web2/arutigliano.html
Unofficial English translation of A Dinâmica do Controle na Anorexia Nervosa, by Ieda Zamel Dorfman and Mara Lucia Rossato, Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, vol. 4, no. 1 (2012), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v4i1.69, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence. Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.
Unofficial English translation of “A Dinâmica do Controle na Anorexia Nervosa”, published in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (2012) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.
Read the original articleHow to cite this article
Dorfman, I. Z., et Rossato, M. L. (2012). The Dynamics of Control in Anorexia Nervosa (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/the-dynamics-of-control-in-anorexia-nervosa (Original work published in 2012 in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, v. 4, n. 1 (2012); republished in 2012 by Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, https://revbrasterapiafamiliar.abratef.org.br/revista/article/view/69)
To go further
Comments 0
Log in to join the discussion. Log in