AI-assisted translation

This version was translated from Italian by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.

Connessioni · Grief

The importance and complexity of multidisciplinary support in perinatal death

Miscarriage, stillbirth, death at birth: in hospital, parents’ pain is often played down by staff who are protecting themselves from burnout. In Palermo, a psychologist, a gynaecologist and the head of the mother-and-child department present ongoing research with 210 bereaved people and 57 health professionals, and the good practices it has brought to light: giving information, allowing time with the dead baby, sharing the pain within the team, and handing on support to an association.

Authors Loredana Antonina Messina (systemic-relational psychotherapist at the Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli Hospital, Palermo, and president of the Georgia Association), Antonio Claudio Cannizzaro (consultant gynaecologist at the Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli Hospital, Palermo) and Maria Rosa D’Anna (Director of the Mother and Child Department, Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli Hospital, Palermo), ItalyFirst published Connessioni, 10 June 2018Translation Complexe Systémique, unofficial translation

Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of L’importanza e la complessità del sostegno multidisciplinare nella morte perinatale, by Loredana Antonina Messina, Antonio Claudio Cannizzaro and Maria Rosa D'Anna, published in Connessioni (Centro Milanese di Terapia della Famiglia), new series, no. 3 (2018), under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Italian text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. The paragraphs and headings are those of the journal; the table, untitled in the original, is presented as a list; quotations, including Freud’s, are translated from the Italian; the year of Di Pietro and Tavella’s book, given as 2016 in the text, is corrected to 2006 from the reference list; a few typographical errors have been silently corrected. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.

The pain that is played down is what remains of the lost child.

Loredana Antonina Messina, Antonio Claudio Cannizzaro, Maria Rosa D'Anna

Introduction

“Having been horrified at the time by the macabre rites of the Movement for Life, which held funerals for fetuses, we did not seek collective ways of working through the loss that many women feel after an abortion. There was nothing to do but put it aside, or at best cry with one’s friends. The fear of giving ground to the opponent paralysed us, and even when this was not entirely the case, and relentless anxieties and dark depressions were voiced, no public discourse was made of them…” (Di Pietro & Tavella, 2006).

These few lines are taken from the book Madri selvagge (“Wild mothers”), which deals with feminism and with the possibility of deliberately terminating a pregnancy. Although abortion is not treated there in terms of loss and grief, but in terms of ideological choices, it is possible to identify in it, too, aspects connected with the need to work through grief, even when it is a conscious choice.

Miscarriage, intrauterine death and perinatal death are considered taboo subjects in today’s society (Cazzaniga, 2017) and, although in recent years we have been witnessing a certain openness, no agreement or shared approach to this issue has yet been found, both because of the delicacy of the subject and because it is still an event that is little talked about. Each health professional handles it subjectively and with more or less sensitivity depending on their personality traits and personal history, without paying attention to the subjective specificity of the parent who loses their child. Even today, attention is paid to the health professional’s communication skills, less to the parents’ experience. In the work I do every day as a psychologist and psychotherapist at the Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli Hospital, and as president of the Georgia Association, I very often hear mothers and fathers apologizing for the pain they feel after learning that their baby’s heartbeat has stopped, and I very often have to listen to colleagues who, through a defensive mechanism of detachment to avoid burnout, play down that pain. Even today, in many hospitals, this bereavement is not received and supported as it should be, and in most cases the aim is to forget and to make others forget, without considering that the pain being played down is what remains of the lost child, and for that very reason all the more difficult to put aside and to work through. It is a continual reification, by health professionals and the health system, of what Enrico Cazzaniga calls the taboo of death.

The “normalizing” behaviours of the health staff who manage the moment of the news, of the delivery and of the postpartum period create significant and disabling limits which often produce a considerable closing off, leading parents and families into isolation. Moreover, even when parents ask for help, they often find themselves dealing with professionals and settings that create a bizarre circuit which does not allow a functional and “natural” process of grieving. Grief is a natural phase of the human life cycle and for this reason should not be pathologized; but when we deal with miscarriages or perinatal deaths, the primary difficulty is precisely the recognition and acceptance of what is apparently not a bereavement. Parents find themselves feeling a pain that they feel, but that they experience as unrecognized by the context in which they live through it, and this creates a dissociative situation, because it is incomprehensible to the human mind. Many people in fact think that such losses are not “worthy” of being considered real bereavements, and this makes conflicting emotions and experiences unmanageable. The effect is that it becomes impossible to move on.

Let us remember that grief is the set of reactions provoked by death in those who remain. As early as 1915, Freud wrote: “Properly speaking, mourning is a reaction to the loss of a loved person or of an abstraction that has taken their place” (Freud, 1976, p. 102). In perinatal death, the concept of the ideal child plays a fundamental part. A mother becomes one when she sees a positive pregnancy test, and it is at that moment that the mind begins a series of thoughts and imaginings that will lead the parents to see their child at various stages of the child’s life and their own. In fact, an early interruption of pregnancy also creates a block in thoughts, which turn from life-giving into deathly. As Enrico Cazzaniga stresses, “a pregnant woman is expecting that child. She already has it. She imagines it, desires it, builds it first of all in her mind, even before her body. This is why prenatal losses are bereavements, often not worked through, forgotten, put aside, frequently overcome by replacing that child with another. But we know that no child is replaceable, just as no person is. This is why, for these children too, it is necessary to grieve, in order then to have room to desire another” (Cazzaniga, 2017).

It should of course be stressed that, in the “game” and the “dance” of connections between systems, while “normalization” is not functional for the parents, who have in fact lost a child, it becomes functional for the doctors, midwives and nurses who have to face death every day and who in this way learn to protect themselves from burnout, or who simply do not know how to handle that specific moment, which they themselves find difficult.

How can we bring these systems, with such different needs, into dialogue?

The meanings of loss

Some components among women who experience a miscarriage, an intrauterine death or a postnatal death are similar and create important connections. Guilt and feeling alone in their pain are elements that recur and are narrated more or less redundantly. However, there are other components, very different from one another, that are linked to the meaning each woman gives to the loss of her child. These reactions inevitably lead us to think that a mother–child relationship exists even before the child is born, and as early as the 1980s Peppers and Knapp (1980) spoke of an attachment bond that begins with planning the pregnancy and grows stronger from the moment fetal movements begin to be felt. Peppers and Knapp identify the moment of birth as the moment when this relationship takes concrete form and is consolidated. Attachment theory, and specifically theories of prenatal attachment, help us understand how intrauterine death is comparable to any other bereavement, even though there are important differences concerning not only personality traits but also the experience of that woman, of that couple, and the history they have lived through. All pregnancies, nowadays, are considered “precious pregnancies”, that is, sought-after pregnancies that come after months and years of attempts and trials, and these inevitably activate parts of the woman who is “expecting”. The condition of expectation concerns not only waiting for the unborn child but also parts of the woman that are activated during pregnancy and give rise to broad reflections on the meaning of being: from being a daughter to being one who conceives and then one who gives birth, and this inevitably activates a sense of continuity that is then contextualized within one’s own family, both the family of origin and the current one.

The unexpected and sudden loss of the pregnancy and of the child creates a rupture that in fact causes a block, the effect of which is a state in which the present is suspended. The experience of loss and powerlessness destabilizes and confuses the connection between the past, what was, and the future, what will be. It is a real bereavement, one that strikes at the sense of belonging, of identity and of existence.

When an ideal baby, or a real one for a very limited lifetime, dies, what happens in the contexts that experienced that baby? When an abortion is selective, what happens? How do parents who are forced to choose feel? Parents and relatives often ask me this question, but there cannot be a single answer, because every story is different and every context carries its own point of view.

The research

Millions of stillbirths occur every year without being recorded and without influencing health policy. In an era of worldwide efforts for maternal health, political and social attention does not include a woman’s natural aspiration to bring a living child into the world, so much so that the recognition of parents’ prenatal and perinatal grief is a recent achievement even in countries with high socio-economic development, such as Europe, Australia and the USA. The results of a survey of health workers and parents in 135 countries show that most babies who die in the womb are taken away from their parents without recognition or rituals such as naming, funeral ceremonies, or the chance to hold or dress them (The Lancet, 2011). A widespread belief is that intrauterine death is the “natural selection” of babies who would not have lived, and for about a third of stillbirths the blame lies with the mother herself or with evil spirits (depending on the culture). It is important to overcome this fatalism, and it is becoming necessary to start thinking about a real “protocol” or “guidelines” with the aim of creating genuine support for perinatal grief, in order to respond to the needs of parents and health professionals.

Starting from these reflections, at the “Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli” Hospital in Palermo, in collaboration with the Georgia Association, which works to protect at-risk pregnancies and provides psychological support and training for professionals in the field, a pilot study was set up; it is currently under way and has so far involved 210 mothers and as many fathers, from Sicily alone. The aim of the research is to create “guidelines” for managing perinatal grief and reducing the risk factors associated with it. Two narrative interviews were designed, one for the parents involved and one for the health staff, which in the first six months of the research made it possible to add complexity to the concept of prenatal and perinatal loss by relating it to hospital and post-hospital comfort care. From August 2017 to February 2018, interviews were carried out with mothers, couples and relatives, for a total of 210 people involved, and with the health staff: 20 gynaecologists, 22 midwives and 15 nurses, for a total of 57 professionals.

Of the couples interviewed, 70% were married and 30% cohabiting; 47% belong to a lower-middle socio-economic background with lower secondary education, 32% to a middle socio-economic background with upper secondary education, and the remaining 21% to an upper-middle socio-economic background with higher education. The mothers’ ages ranged from 16 to 52, with both single and twin pregnancies. Pregnancies defined as physiological and mothers with a previous experience of miscarriage or intrauterine death were not included in the research. Four variables were considered with regard to gestational age: death by miscarriage up to week 27; IUFD, or intrauterine death from week 27 onwards; loss during or immediately after delivery; and postpartum death caused by severe conditions incompatible with life. All the interviews took place during the hospital stay and at a follow-up three months later at the premises of the Georgia Association.

Table

  • Women: miscarriage (death in the womb up to 27 weeks’ gestation), 43; IUFD (intrauterine death from 27 to 40 weeks), 10; perinatal loss (during delivery or immediately after), 11; pregnancies with an outcome incompatible with life, 16; couples who continued with “Georgia”, 52.
  • Couples: miscarriage, 23; IUFD, 10; perinatal loss, 11; pregnancies with an outcome incompatible with life, 10; couples who continued with “Georgia”, 11.
  • Relatives: miscarriage, 42; IUFD, 23; perinatal loss, 4; pregnancies with an outcome incompatible with life, 7; couples who continued with “Georgia”, 0.

Partial results of the research (currently under way)

The partial data obtained from the research indicate that 96% of the couples followed from the beginning of the process (by beginning we mean the moment when the terrible news was given to the parents) through to after discharge reported:

  • less guilt about the cause of death,
  • less anger towards themselves and towards the doctors,
  • more cooperation with and more trust in the health staff during the hospital stay.

These 3 simple but important elements currently seem to be risk factors which, if not managed and contained, can lead to non-acceptance of the event, a block in the grieving process and, therefore, possible complications for the family members’ future well-being.

The research is still in progress, so the data cannot yet be published in full, but we can state that, over time and in the work carried out both at the “Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli” Hospital and at the “Georgia” Association, we have understood that the critical points just mentioned can be transformed into resources if multidisciplinary work is set up involving gynaecologists, neonatologists, psychologists, midwives and nurses, dedicated to supporting and activating the resources present in the parental couple at the acute moment of the psychological rupture, and to preventing the effects of trauma that has not been worked through. It is a continual and systemic activation of inner resources that in fact brings about “a lightening of the event”, both for the parental couple, who feel welcomed and understood in their pain, and for the professionals in the field, who feel less need to rely on mechanisms for denying their own emotional resonances when they encounter the other’s pain.

The work done shows that support on several levels and with several systems has enabled many couples to pass through the loss, to get past the temporal block in the past, to allow themselves time to live the pain in the present, and to find a new personal meaning for this event within their own story, projecting themselves into the future. We are referring to what Cazzaniga calls the “care of remembrance”, that is, “the possibility of securing the memory of the one who is no longer here, but who lives on and is part of the story” (Cazzaniga, 2017).

Today we can say that among good practices we recognize: 1) giving information about the laws in force and explaining the procedure that will be followed over the next 24 hours, to allow parents an “informed choice”; 2) offering time to be with the dead baby, spending the first hours after delivery physically together; 3) giving them time to experience that baby lost too soon; 4) allowing health staff to share that pain which, if experienced individually, becomes unmanageable, but when shared becomes more bearable and easier to face.

We also believe that collaboration between public hospital facilities and local associations is equally important in fostering complete support, both within the hospital context in the acute phase and over the broader and longer period outside the ward and beyond the hospital stay, respecting the needs of the couple and of the family. Within the “Georgia” Association, “talking groups” are run in which people can share their experience with other parents who have been through the same experience of bereavement. This allows parents, in the acute phase, to see that it is possible to survive and manage the intense pain of their baby’s death, and, at a later stage of grieving, it fosters the telling of new stories, with new developmental meanings attributed to their own story.

Enrico Cazzaniga writes in his latest publication:

“grief is a new space-time of life: the time needed to mend the tear, to integrate the past with the present, to find oneself facing an unknown future and to remember with nostalgia the one who is no longer here. Then the dead are alive within us, in memory, and among us, in the narratives of our relationships”

and goes on to say

“when grief is resolved, it means that we have placed in the past the person who is no longer in the present. That person is alive in the present through memory. This is the care of remembrance” (Cazzaniga, 2017).

I believe that, in perinatal grief, to make the care of remembrance possible, we must first put in place good practices that make legitimate the pain that this loss imposes.

Final reflections

The obstetrics ward of the “Buccheri La Ferla Fatebenefratelli” Hospital is a ward that in recent years has focused its efforts on improving communication and collaboration between the various systems involved, by emphasizing the importance of multidisciplinarity as a resource within a context as complex as a hospital. This has resulted in greater integration of the different professions and scientific languages through attention to managing relational dynamics. In this context, the psychologist acts as a “mediator” of communication between hospital management, medical and nursing staff and parents, making it better suited to the parents’ needs for emotional “containment”, after the trauma of an early and often abrupt interruption of gestation, and to their need to adapt to a new idea of parenthood that differs from the one they had imagined. This is achieved through a “re-signification” of what happened, which gives a new “meaning” to the very idea of parenthood. The constant presence of the psychologist on the ward also provides a space for “listening” to the emotions of the staff, who are often overwhelmed by conflicting feelings which, if not properly managed, can lead to an increased risk of burnout and work-related stress. Equally important, as a protective factor, is improving communication about the legal information, which provides the normative space within which to move and to guide the parents’ informed decisions, and which fosters greater cooperation on the parents’ part, both in the acute phase and afterwards. In addition, the possibility of donating milk has allowed mothers, in cases of perinatal death, to give their loss a different meaning, no longer linked exclusively to missing or interrupted generativity, but to the possibility of offering nourishment that is functional and suitable for the growth and development of other newborns. The passage from death to life.

The way the ward is run, and the possibility of offering a ward that is cooperative and collaborative, has shown a reduction in risk factors that benefits not only the parental couple but also the whole family system and the professionals who revolve around it. The effects of support configured in this way, moreover, prove functional for a positive recovery of motherhood and fatherhood, strongly countering depression and fostering the rebuilding of a family balance that is inevitably put to the test by the loss of a baby, at whatever gestational age.

Complexe Systémique: key points

The text matters less for its data, which are partial and presented without a detailed method (the figures do not quite tally: 210 mothers and as many fathers, then 210 people in all), than for its reading of the systems involved. The “normalization” of perinatal death appears as a functional solution for staff, who protect themselves from burnout in this way, and a dysfunctional one for parents, whose grief goes unrecognized: two legitimate needs that contradict each other and have to be brought into dialogue. The response proposed is systemic in the most concrete sense: a psychologist mediating on the ward, listening time for the staff, clear legal information, time for parents with their dead baby, and then the support of an association and talking groups. For clinical practice, one idea to keep is Enrico Cazzaniga’s “care of remembrance”: giving the lost child a place in the family story rather than replacing them. Milk donation, presented as a passage “from death to life”, would deserve more cautious discussion. Read alongside the Spanish study of the impact of perinatal death on the family, and the study of parental guilt after the death of a child.

References

Cazzaniga E. (2001), La famiglia, la perdita e il lutto, in AA.VV., Psiconcologia, Milano, Masson, Milano.

Cazzaniga E. (2005), L’approccio narrativo-relazionale al lutto, in Ad occhi aperti. La relazione d’aiuto alla fine della vita e nelle esperienze di perdita, Ed. Libreria Cortina Verona.

Cazzaniga E. (2017), Il lutto, Outis, Monza.

Cozza G. (2010), Quando l’attesa si interrompe, Il leone verde, Torino.

Di Pietro A., Tavella P.(2006), Madri selvagge: Contro la tecnorapina del corpo femminile, Torino, Einaudi.

Freud, S. (1976), Lutto e malinconia, in Opere, vol. 8, Torino, Bollati Boringhieri.

Lawn, J. E.; Kinney, M. (2011), “Executive Summary”, The lancet, aprile 2011 (acc. 9 giugno 2018).

Mori, M. (1996), Aborto e morale: Capire un nuovo diritto, Torino, Einaudi.

Riccio, M. (2017), La cicogna distratta: Il paradigma sistemico relazionale nella clinica della sterilità e dell’infertilità di coppia, Milano, Franco Angeli.

Scirè, G. (2008), L’aborto in Italia. Storia di una legge, Milano, Mondadori.

Testoni, I. (2011), Dopo la notizia peggiore, Padova, Piccin-Nuova Libraria.

Unofficial English translation of L’importanza e la complessità del sostegno multidisciplinare nella morte perinatale, by Loredana Antonina Messina, Antonio Claudio Cannizzaro and Maria Rosa D'Anna, Connessioni, new series, no. 3 (2018), under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence (table presented as a list). Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.

Unofficial English translation of “L’importanza e la complessità del sostegno multidisciplinare nella morte perinatale”, published in Connessioni (2018) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.

Read the original article

How to cite this article

Messina, L. A., Cannizzaro, A. C., et D'Anna, M. R. (2018). The importance and complexity of multidisciplinary support in perinatal death (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/the-importance-and-complexity-of-multidisciplinary-support-in-perinatal-death (Original work published in 2018 in Connessioni, nuova serie, n. 3 (2018); republished in 2018 by Connessioni, https://connessioni.cmtf.it/limportanza-e-la-complessita-del-sostegno-multidisciplinare-nella-morte-perinatale/)

Discussion

Comments 0

Log in to join the discussion. Log in

  1. No comment yet. Start the discussion.

Cart

Your cart is empty.