This version was translated from Italian by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.
Connessioni · Group therapy
In spring 2020, in the middle of lockdown, two closed, all-female groups meet by videoconference, with participants from Italy, Spain, Turkey and Chile. Cinzia Giordano draws from them guidelines for online systemic group therapy: precautions in setting the frame, the signals the screen erases, and the place of the room from which each person connects. The participants’ accounts describe an emotional intensity and a sense of belonging close to those of face-to-face groups.
Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of Terapia di gruppo online, by Cinzia Giordano, published in Connessioni (Centro Milanese di Terapia della Famiglia), new series, no. 8 (2020), under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Italian text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. The paragraphs and subheadings are those of the journal; Carlos Castaneda’s epigraph, broken into lines in the journal, the participants’ accounts and the extract from Giordano and Curino (2013), italicized in the journal, are set as block quotations; quotations are translated from the Italian, except Castaneda’s epigraph, given in its English wording, with the English title of the book; other titles of works are given as the article cites them; a few typographical errors have been silently corrected. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.
Online group therapy today is indeed a different but real experience.
Cinzia Giordano
… ask yourself, and yourself alone, one question:
does this path have a heart?
If it does, the path is good; if it doesn’t, it is of no use.
Carlos Castaneda, The Teachings of Don Juan
The first Macy Conference, in 1946, was made possible by a catastrophic event that had marked the life of Kate Macy Ladd (Bertrando and Toffanetti, 2000): her father died during a typhoid fever epidemic when she was only a child. Years later, she decided to face this grief by funding a meeting of outstanding minds who were able to engage with one another, creatively connecting fields of knowledge that until then had seemed far apart.
“Between us and things as they are there is always a creative filter” (Bateson and Bateson, 1989): in times of catastrophe, the creative filter, driven by the urge to survive, can generate novelty.
This year the world was overwhelmed by a catastrophic pandemic that weighed heavily on lives and relationships. During the Covid-19 epidemic, China, Italy and then the whole world were forced to put in place extreme measures of social distancing to contain the pandemic; these measures went as far as lockdown, upsetting habits and the ordinary routines of personal and professional life.
Where the pandemic prevented it, spreading loneliness and fear among people, the need to maintain social relationships found a valuable ally in the wide international reach of the internet and in technology accessible to more and more people.
We therefore found ourselves experimenting with new ways of working, developing online activity that was already present in our lives but very little used in psychotherapy.
Could we move towards a creative act that would bring something new? I wanted to see whether the complex network of interactions that develops within a therapy group could really be managed remotely; whether it was possible to reduce complexity, giving up physical presence, without losing the variety and richness of the experience.
So I decided to set up two groups, with the collaboration and participation of colleagues experienced in systemic therapy.
Both groups were closed and online. The trials ended in July 2020. In both cases the groups were exclusively female.
The first group, made up of eight people aged 24 to 35, was therapeutic, while the second, made up of six people aged 25 to 55, was an experiential training group on the systemic management of groups.
The participants and colleagues lived in several countries: Italy, Spain, Turkey and Chile.
For the first group I had the valuable collaboration of colleagues from the University of Chile in Santiago: Felipe Gálvez Sánchez, an academic in the department of psychology, and Daniela Lagos, who teaches on the diploma course in systemic family therapy.
I was trying to understand whether we were resigning ourselves to the digital dimension or whether, within it, it was possible to think of integrating the old with the new while keeping the quality and effectiveness of the tool.
It was also possible to push the tool of systemic group therapy towards application in a multicultural context, made naturally accessible by the abolition of distances that the internet allowed and still allows us.
As I prepared for the experience, it was clear to me that certain differences of context had to be recognized, requiring specific attention when the rules were defined. Since the meeting would not take place in a shared physical location but on a virtual platform, and people would be in their own private surroundings during the session, it was necessary to remind them that these places had to guarantee privacy for themselves and for the other members of the group. Even other family members simply passing through the room could have undermined the sense of safety and protection needed in order to open up. And since, to make the relational dynamic more fluid and natural, I asked participants to keep their microphones and cameras on at all times, these had to be places where it was possible to concentrate and not be disturbed, avoiding as far as possible distractions and background noise in the eight to ten real rooms from which people were connecting. Microphones and cameras switched off, by preventing the usual non-verbal feedback, could moreover have encouraged, for some, the emergence of projective experiences that would be difficult to manage.
It was also necessary to make explicit both the ban on participants recording the sessions, something that current technology makes all too easy, and the need to ensure a sufficiently stable network connection, so as to avoid interruptions or interference in the work. In the event of connection problems, the participant knows that she will have to arrange to rejoin, and when the work is co-led, whichever facilitator is less active at that moment takes care of helping to solve the problem, without the group having to stop.
With both groups, as with online activity in general, it was not, and is not always, possible to meet participants in person before the group begins. Interventions therefore need to be delicate, since one cannot accurately assess the possible effects, visible or otherwise, of a given perturbation.
Consider too that, in order for everyone to be connected together in group therapy, ten windows are on the screen at the same time, so the visibility of each participant is much reduced compared with an individual session. To gain better visibility of the course of the therapy and of each individual participant, in some situations I felt it necessary to consider having participants write individual reflections, to be sent to the therapist between one session and the next. This level of communication proved useful for getting to know the individual parts hidden by the video-call tool and for keeping a finger on the pulse of the group’s progress.
I also told participants that I would consider the possibility of individual moments with each of them should it prove necessary. This tool proved useful in moments of subjective impasse. Such meetings can also be held remotely, with the support of all the technological tools at our disposal.
The very nature of the online tool sets certain objective limits on the perception of what is happening, from the point of view of both the therapist and the participants.
In group work, people get to know and recognize one another through what they have built together, through stories and faces, within the limits of each virtual window.
I therefore had to consider carefully what can and cannot be seen through the screen, aware that the vantage points change.
Direct observation gives us access mainly to facial expressions, to the movements of the upper body, to the way the voice is modulated, and to the presence of elements of a familiar setting that, deliberately or not, appear in one’s own frame during the connection.
We can certainly observe silences, which in this context may take on less obvious meanings: one may ask, for example, whether there is a difficulty in taking the floor due to the digital medium, whether these are reflective silences or whether they hold back expectations. What is certain is that the greater potential for misunderstanding and ambiguity inherent in this situation makes even more careful verbalization and explicitness necessary. Greater prompting is thus needed from the facilitator, while participants express a more explicit intention to speak.
The online tool reduces the possibility of observing the usual non-verbal micro-signals. The range of stimuli that govern the flow of communication thus loses breadth and variety, making conversation more demanding.
It is much more difficult, for example, to perceive the intake of breath that in ordinary conversation signals the intention to begin speaking. The intensity and rhythm of breathing are, moreover, signals that contribute powerfully to contextualization and to the process of attributing meaning to communications. Sometimes, indeed, a simple sigh is already in itself a meaningful communication.
The proxemic elements linked to the reciprocity of gazes among participants, and between participants and facilitators, also appear limited, with distorting effects due to the position of the cameras, which is offset from the eyes in the image of the person one is speaking to. The movements that orient attention through posture are also missing. Nor is it possible to make physical gestures of drawing closer. Likewise, the anticipatory signs of agreement and disagreement are less perceptible.
If we consider in this regard the second axiom of the pragmatics of human communication, we can say that online communication leaves the verbal content almost intact, but deprives it of some of the relational aspects and signals that make up the metacommunication needed to specify how the content is to be interpreted. To return to Bateson (Ruesch and Bateson, 1968), what remains in the flow of communication is the “report” part, that is, the content, while the “command” part, that is, the metacommunication that provides instructions on how to interpret the content, is significantly altered.
The reduction of this complex apparatus of signals leaves communication to be qualified mainly by its auditory aspects, which calls for greater explicitness about the metacommunicative aspects.
Empathy, the capacity to perceive “in one’s own body” what the other is feeling, is largely governed by neurological responses connected with the possibility of observing and “mirroring” the other (Bandler and Grinder, 1981).
Mirroring, which is the basis for building rapport, that is, a relationship of trust, normally takes place on both the physical and the verbal level; in online group therapy, however, the verbal aspect becomes clearly predominant and therefore also requires close visual attention to the eight frames on the screen, in which one can partly see and partly sense the emotions the participants are feeling, so as to give them voice where appropriate.
The reduction of the means of checking can encourage misunderstandings of interpretation, leaving room for negative but also positive projective dynamics.
The possibility of connecting people in different parts of the world required attention to time zones and to the language to be used in leading the group. It also meant considering examples and metaphors scrupulously, so that they would be meaningful to everyone.
In one of the groups held during the first lockdown, three nationalities were present, Italian, Turkish and Chilean, and topics such as belonging, freedom and being oneself had a very different impact on the Italian participants than on the Chilean ones, who carried specific social histories, with different experiences linked to the political events surrounding the dictatorship.
In these situations it is important to pay attention to how the different kinds of knowledge are integrated, bringing them out so that they can become a resource for everyone rather than being experienced as a difference or a distance.
Participation in both groups was, on everyone’s part, very active and engaged, although for some there was a brief initial moment of worry and disorientation.
In most cases the people did not know one another, but all of them were sharing the experience of facing the pandemic and the lockdown.
The introduction phase allowed each person to think about what to share of herself. Being able to watch the others open up produced a domino effect of personal disclosures, in which the quality of the communications, though limited by the medium, gradually produced a strong relational intensity, with a very rapid sense of sharing that gave access to a feeling that experiences were legitimate and universal.
In one of the two groups, in fact, about forty minutes after the start of the first session, there arose what the participants called “a hurricane of emotions” “inside a single room”, even though each was in her own room.
The desire to connect with the others on the basis of similarities tended to grow during the interactions, and the more people connected, the greater the desire to break down the technological barriers. It was interesting to note that involvement could be as strong as in face-to-face meetings.
The intensity of the emotions present, and the openness with which they were shared, lent and lived through the stories told, made people feel physically distant and at the same time very intimate and close, “inside a single room” indeed, with the feeling that they could trust and entrust themselves, in communion and connection with one another, rapidly developing a strong sense of universality in I. Yalom’s sense (1992).
Once the experience was over, the participants were asked to describe what they had lived through.
Let us be guided along the way by their words.
Alessandra on the first session:
“At the beginning of the session I felt different emotions. I was frustrated at not being able to be in the same room as the members of the group; the atmosphere seemed cold to me, and I think this was because we were not in contact with the same objects, the same smells and sounds as the others. Everyone was inside their own bubble. At the same time I was curious to hear the stories of people I did not know, and a little sceptical about the kind of emotional involvement I might experience towards them.
When the introductions began, I felt that each bubble was starting to stir and that this movement created warmth. I sensed a little embarrassment both in myself and in some of the members of the group. I thought that, being far away, in my room, I would not get flustered the way I do when I have to introduce myself in person. Yet even in this situation, embarrassment took over the moment forcefully. Perhaps, beyond the tools we use, it is contexts that bring out certain redundant reactions.
When we began to tell our stories, I sensed that our bubbles, with floating and delicate movements, were drawing closer and closer, and some even joined together. […] Thanks to some of the stories and the emotions coming from the others, I felt that I could trust […] I felt very close to the group and to their stories; the emotions I felt were as intense as those felt in non-virtual groups. […] Towards the end of the session it seemed to me that, in some way, each of us had been activated by the others’ stories, and I had the impression that none of us wanted to leave the group, that we still wanted to tell and to listen.”
The experiences that Alessandra tells us about were present, in different words, in the communications of other participants too. Many reported astonishment at the intensity of their involvement, despite the virtual setting. Alessandra indeed grasps a central point: the importance of creating the context through the definition of rules and themes, the choice of participants, and a way of intervening that is respectful of everyone.
Online too, Cecchin’s curiosity (1987) and the absence of judgement define the reassuring space in which people can truly know others and make themselves known.
Alessandra adds that:
“After the session ended, the quiet weeping that the group had stirred in me found its way through that small crack and welled up more intensely; being in my room, protected, with no prying eyes staring at me, allowed this very strong emotion to emerge, painful at times but perhaps necessary. It lasted quite a while, coming back at intervals, until I felt completely emptied, connected with the present, calm. I reflected that if the session had ended in a room where we were physically present, where I would probably have started chatting with the members of the group and then would have had to take public transport home surrounded by strangers, I almost certainly would not have been able to live that flow of such intense emotions but would have had to hold them back, and I don’t think that would have done me any good.”
Several accounts show how feeling protected within one’s own living environment allows freer and sometimes more intense emotional access. It seems that, for some, experiencing the sessions in a setting that is already personal may reduce the need to suspend the emotional flow temporarily by putting on the social mask that usually protects us in interactions experienced as carrying a risk of judgement. This mode certainly represents a difference that may be an opportunity for some and a limitation for others.
In regulating emotional work, a suspension of the emotional flow may in fact act, for some, as a useful cooling of an excessively intense process, while for others it may become a reinforcement of defence mechanisms based on denial.
Being “at home” offers some protection from the tension felt when attending the first session of a face-to-face group. One’s own surroundings are reassuring at first, but as the sessions follow one another, people begin to miss being able to share spaces physically.
A wish to meet arises; compared with face-to-face sessions, the desire to welcome the others into one’s own living spaces is strongly expressed, as if having opened up while at home had increased intimacy with the group.
Mara says:
“[…] I feel a great bond with all the people in the group, a bond I would also like to cultivate physically over time… The group is inside me, in my experiences that resonate, in my sensations, in my emotions and in my thoughts.”
Aspects were shared that are not directly part of the therapy but that, from a certain point onwards, nonetheless become part of it.
Without meaning to, people have already opened their homes to those with whom they have shared important stories, and this allows the group to feel united in a form that is more than the sum of its parts.
Anna thinks of the group
“[…] as an impressionist canvas in which the colours are not mixed but applied pure to the canvas, and in which the image is always the same but is captured from different facets, in which light is fundamental because it manages to give the viewer different sensations. There, I see myself as one of those pure colours that are brought out by the light and by the beauty of the colours surrounding them.”
We were inside eight stories and at the same time inside a single one, as in a fractal, that is, a design in which the same form recurs in the whole and in each of its parts. The group itself is at once the creator of a system of meanings and a creature that takes shape through its members while representing them. Each person could thus recognize as legitimate and shared within the group what she had felt in her heart.
The place where each participant settles for the session matters not only because it must guarantee confidentiality for oneself and for the other participants; its importance also lies in the fact that this place may have particular meanings for the patient. We must indeed be aware that this place is not the therapist’s consulting room, but could be a room with a history.
What history does that room have for the person taking part in the session?
What life, what emotions and what constraints have been or are habitually experienced in that place?
The fact that the meeting space is not a neutral place may also bring with it the limitation that it is harder to open up freely to the group, given the repeated habit in that place of holding oneself back in order to adapt better to the context; for this reason it may become necessary to explore its meanings.
It is important to understand how the patient’s Identity Focus is situated within the therapeutic context, given that being in one’s usual living environment could make it harder to leave behind habitual processes of meaning-making and connect with the group.
As we have already written (Giordano and Curino, 2013, p. 66):
“We can define […] as the Identity Focus (IF) the place where a person subjectively locates the intersection of the relationships that define their survival. At the beginning of life it is unconsciously and naturally centred on the fusional mother/child relationship; as the child grows, it shifts more and more to include other significant contexts of reference.
The IF is identified on the basis of a series of instantaneous interactions. On each single occasion the Focus is located at the intersection of the relationships existing at that specific moment, which bear on the space of existence and personal security in that momentary context. These are Occasional Foci (OF).
Some of these OF recur continuously and repeatedly in the experience of the subject, who tends to attribute greater relevance to that particular configuration, defining it as IF.”
The IF is normally connected to the place where recurring interactions occur, and that place could well be the setting in which the person happens to be taking part in the session.
These contextual data may in some way slow down access to change, making the therapeutic process more laborious; but I hypothesize that if, during the sessions, it becomes possible to overcome the constraints that have so conditioned one’s history, they are already being overcome in the very environment where this change is needed. In this sense it is as if the group and its processes of meaning-making burst into the family space, becoming predominant or at least modifying the predominant view.
Let us take an example: if I have always lived in a family where everyone supports team A and despises those who support team B, I will probably have got used to never shouting “Go B!” But if, suddenly, the therapy group, made up of team B supporters, bursts into my home, it will be easier for me to allow myself a liberating “Go B!” Contempt and appreciation will then settle into a different balance, since I will have perturbed my external and internal system, understanding the real meaning the subject has for me.
Greater initial effort could therefore lead to an even faster therapeutic result.
There are different qualities of belonging, all linked to the weight of context in modulating the dimension of security in life. A strong sense of belonging also arises in a mafia clan or a religious sect. In that case, in my view, it is a kind of belonging founded on fear and insecurity about one’s own physical or emotional survival. This quality of belonging is founded on judgement and on the fear of it.
In the groups we led, by contrast, the sense of belonging was based on trust and on the security of being able to open up in a supportive context characterized by freedom and the absence of judgement. The facilitator’s task is to create this specific kind of environment, which is necessary for people to feel free to develop a quality of belonging that fosters learning.
In this regard, Miriam recounts:
“[…] When I felt I was suffering in a session, I knew my distress would not fall into a void. There was always someone ready to see it and to ‘gather it up’ […]. I am absolutely certain that this will not be a goodbye; after all, when so many hearts have met, as they did for us, it is no longer possible to forget one another.”
The experience Miriam describes was often reported by other group participants as well.
It is as if an inner group had formed within each person, allowing them, even after the sessions have ended, to live their own experiences by drawing on the memory of the other participants’ stories, multiplying the possible points of view and solutions while accepting and legitimizing their own.
Marta states:
“[…] I will carry all the people who were part of this group in my heart; each of them left me something that has changed me forever…”
And Marina:
“[…] I experienced a sense of shared participation, of feeling part of an empathic group, of reflecting on my own story through the experiences told by others, of discovering that other people too come up against difficulties similar or analogous to mine. […] As far as I am concerned, the awareness that I am not alone in facing the shadows of the past, and that I am part of a group walking the path towards freedom, gives me great energy.”
The emotional bond with the group seems to help overcome the loneliness that always characterizes the sense of powerlessness and unfreedom in limiting contexts.
A sense of belonging to the group develops online too. Some described it as a moment in which to feel they had value, all the more so at a time when social isolation can cause the usual points of reference to be lost.
Feeling relevant, being thought of, increases the sense of personal security that makes it possible to venture towards change. Silvia expresses this thought clearly when she describes her experience:
“[…] after the session I missed, they wrote to me in our WhatsApp group to tell me what they had talked about, to ask how I was and to say they had missed me. I felt so happy! I really felt part of the group and I felt that I was important.”
The groups were held during the spring 2020 lockdown, when all the participants were exposed for the first time in their lives to extremely severe social deprivation, which may have increased the need for contact. I wonder whether what I observed would be repeatable and generalizable outside these very particular conditions.
This experience has certainly made it clear that online group therapy is not merely comparable to face-to-face therapy, but can be a tool that, with particular care, can facilitate certain processes of change.
Giuliani (2019) says that the virtual is real, but in a different way. Online group therapy today is indeed a different but real experience.
It proved to be an engaging and reflective practice. The behaviours and emotions that usually emerge as a face-to-face group develops reappeared online, together with qualitatively new phenomena, probably linked in part to the fact of welcoming the participants into their own living spaces.
We experienced that people can embrace virtually, but above all that they can laugh and cry together, feel that they matter to others, feel that they are important.
So far, only the factor of “conflict” has not been particularly present. It may be hypothesized that this depended on the specific characteristics of the groups led, but also on the way they were led. Interventions were in fact offered with greater delicacy than in face-to-face meetings, which was made necessary by our lesser knowledge of the participants. Being online may also have made defensive reactions less necessary.
Returning to the initial questions: are we moving towards a creative act?
Can we think of integrating the old with the new?
One approach I intend to try as soon as possible is to lead systemic therapy groups alternating, as needed, face-to-face sessions with online sessions in which participants welcome into their own living spaces, virtually but really, the system of meanings created by the group.
Complexe Systémique: key points
This is a clinical account rather than a study: two small, all-female groups run during the first lockdown, with no measures or comparison, and accounts gathered at the end by the person leading them. The context of social deprivation and the absence of conflict, which the article itself notes, call for caution before generalizing. Its value lies elsewhere. The text treats the room from which each person connects as a context in its own right: a place charged with family history, which may hold back openness but may also locate change exactly where it needs to happen. Asking “What history does this room have for you?” becomes a genuinely systemic question in videoconference work. There are also practical pointers: cameras and microphones on, no recording, the co-facilitator stepping in when a connection drops, written reflections between sessions, an individual meeting in moments of impasse, and above all more explicit metacommunication when non-verbal signals grow thin. “Home” proves double-edged: freer access to emotion for some, the loss of a useful protection for others. Read alongside online multifamily therapy in Hong Kong, and relational teletherapy as experienced by clients.
References
Bandler, R.; Grinder, J. (1981), La struttura della magia, Roma, Astrolabio Ubaldini.
Bateson, G.; Bateson, M. C. (1987), Angels Fear. Towards an Epistemology of the Sacred, Chicago, University of Chicago Press. Trad. It. Dove gli angeli esitano, Milano, Adelphi, 1989.
Bertrando, P.; Toffanetti, D., (2000), Storia della terapia familiare. Le persone, le idee, Milano, Cortina.
Castaneda, C. (1999), Gli insegnamenti di don Juan, Milano, Rizzoli.
Cecchin, G. (1987), “Hypotesizing, Circularity and Neutrality Revisited: an Invitation to Curiosity”, Family Process, 26, 405-413. Trad. it: “Revisione dei concetti di Ipotizzazione, Circolarità, Neutralita: un Invito alla Curiosità”, Ecologia della mente, n. 5, 1988.
Giordano, C.; Curino, M. G. (2013) Terapia sistemica di gruppo, Roma, Alpes.
Giuliani, M. (2012), Ipotesi sul Sé: Dalla psicoanalisi al virtuale, in Barbetta, P.; Casadio, L.; Giuliani, M. (a cura di), Margini: Tra sistemica e psicoanalisi, Torino, Antigone.
Giuliani, M. (2019), La terapia online, in Barbetta, P.; Telfener, U. (a cura di), Complessità e psicoterapia. L’eredità di Boscolo e Cecchin, Milano, Raffaello Cortina.
Ruesch, J.; Bateson, G. (1968), La Matrice Sociale della Psichiatria, Bologna, Il Mulino.
Yalom, I. (1992), Teoria e pratica della psicoterapia di gruppo, Bollati, Boringhieri.
Unofficial English translation of Terapia di gruppo online, by Cinzia Giordano, Connessioni, new series, no. 8 (2020), under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence. Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.
Unofficial English translation of “Terapia di gruppo online”, published in Connessioni (2020) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.
Read the original articleHow to cite this article
Giordano, C. (2020). Online group therapy (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/online-group-therapy (Original work published in 2020 in Connessioni, nuova serie, n. 8 (2020); republished in 2020 by Connessioni, https://connessioni.cmtf.it/terapia-di-gruppo-online/)
To go further
Comments 0
Log in to join the discussion. Log in