This version was translated from Portuguese by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.
Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar · Ecology and mental health
Eco-anxiety, eco-guilt, ecological grief: climate crises are entering family therapy sessions. Drawing on forty years of practice and twenty years of psychological aid after disasters in Brazil, Ana Maria Fonseca Zampieri takes the word apocalypse in its sense of revelation and invites family therapists to think about the mental health of families together with that of the planet, through ecopsychology and the voices of disaster survivors.
Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of Apocalipse e terapia familiar: saúde planetária e ecopsicologia, by Ana Maria Fonseca Zampieri, published in the Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (ABRATEF), vol. 12, no. e0224 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.137, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Brazilian Portuguese text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. Paragraphs and headings are those of the journal; the long quotation is set as a block quote; a passage drawn from lines by E. E. Cummings is replaced by an editor’s note, and lines by Walt Whitman, quoted in a Portuguese translation, are reported in indirect speech; end-of-article statements are grouped in the notes. The abstract is the author’s own English version. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.
Family therapists can be part of the chorus that builds the voice that sustains and makes possible peace in planetary health.
Ana Maria Fonseca Zampieri
Abstract
The author articulates concepts from family therapy, Ecopsychology, planetary health and climate crises with new challenges in family mental health. It associates the term apocalypse with the opportunity to reveal reflections on therapeutic actions in the settings of family therapies, which promote paradigmatic deconstructions, which lead to awareness and recognition of the inevitable interconnections between human beings and their belonging to nature. It invites family therapists to discussions linked to eco-anxieties, eco-guilt, ecological grief, and other biophobic anxieties, present explicitly and implicitly in the protagonists of the family therapy stage.
Keywords: Family therapy. Planetary health. Ecopsychology.
“The light is waiting to be felt by us in visions of a new paradigm and a new kind of culture that we can all create,” says Carolyn Baker (2020). Is the apocalypse approaching? Apocaluptein, from the Greek, means to lift the veil, to reveal. What can a fantasy, a myth or a concrete threat of ecological apocalypse reveal to us? Little by little, perhaps very slowly, we are lifting the veil on the part that the separation between humans and nature plays in the exhaustion of our planet Earth. Are we so attached to our mother Earth, as Morin and Kern (2023) assert, that we cannot accept the weaning necessary for our human evolution?
On the stages of family therapy, where we have been actively present for more than four decades, we perceive how deep, constructive changes are spasmodic and can germinate in the disruptive, from something that has collapsed, crumbled and been born into the unknown (Lederach, 2011).
In the complex thinking developed in family therapies, we encounter these protagonists more and more often: the Earth, deaths, apocalypses, destructions, repetitions, quests, sufferings and pleasures. How many automatic actions deceive us in the imbroglios of the meanings of the human/nature relationship? How does the training of family therapists need to include ecopsychology?
The locus of family therapy is one of the precious opportunities for making visible, and bringing into awareness, the circuits of exchange of values, beliefs, meanings and behaviours that feed back on one another throughout the family life cycle. Observing, as participants, the intrinsic relationships, hidden and/or explicit, between their themes and planetary health may foster and broaden awareness of the coexistence of distinct perspectives, which need to be legitimized for the mental health of all of us, in the process of living this twenty-first century.
In the various family therapy forums in Brazil, especially since the time of Covid-19, we have been discussing how to relate among ourselves and with nature, as part of the same communicative ecosystem. The social scientist and climatologist Bendell (2020) states that we must prepare ourselves emotionally and practically to minimize a possible collapse on planet Earth.
[Here the author takes up, in the form of a question, lines by E. E. Cummings (Cummings, 2016) about the illusion of always arriving at the place one never left. — Editor’s note.] It is important that all of us, and here I include family therapists, ask the questions: how do we conserve what we truly want to conserve? How can we explore renunciations of consumerism in order to help people who are experiencing terror, pain and confusion? How can we restore actions and life projects without fuelling our civilization with hydrocarbons, the geological processes through which commercial accumulations such as oil, natural gas and coal, among others, are formed? And, finally, how can we create ways of living in the world with reconciliations among ourselves, among relatives, societies, cultures, peoples, religions, genders, politics and generations?
As family therapists, we can inspire everyone to think about overcoming hopelessness and to co-construct loving here and now. In this regard, Pope Francis (2023) published the Apostolic Exhortation Laudate Deum: to all people of good will on the climate crisis, in which he states that everything is interconnected and that no one is saved alone. Nature is not a mere frame in which our family lives develop our existences and projects. We are one! Fratelli tutti, in postmodern culture, is a call for sensitivity towards the most fragile and those with the least power. This publication by Pope Francis, dated 4 October 2023, is in keeping with the current proposals of ecopsychology, with its contributions on the deep and reciprocal relationship between humans in nature, and invites us to an ecological health of bonds, attentive to the ecological unconscious, to the persistence in destroying the Earth without knowing that we do not know, and to the search for ways of confronting the self-destructive blindness of a biophobic, narcissistic and self-referential humanity.
The 27th United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP27), in Sharm El-Sheikh, in 2022, in the midst of the invasion of Ukraine, warned the world that the goal set at COP21 in Paris (2015), keeping the rise in global average temperatures below 2 °C, would not be met. COP28, held in Dubai, in the United Arab Emirates, ended with a historic agreement on transitioning from fossil fuels to clean and renewable energy sources. On 13 December 2023, the Secretary-General of the United Nations (UN), António Guterres, declared:
I also salute all those who fought for the most robust possible outcome, including civil society and young people around the world. COP28 took place at a decisive moment in the fight against the climate crisis, a moment that demands maximum ambition, both in reducing greenhouse gases and in climate justice… and multilateralism remains humanity’s best hope…
Brazil has offered to host COP30, in the Amazon, in 2025.
Will these so-called urgently needed goals be able to take into account which families will be involved, assisted and prepared for the many challenges of the actions needed for well-being and mental health? Will there be effective action, beyond what is recorded on paper? For our part, as family therapists in Brazil, we seek theoretical and methodological exchanges for preventive and therapeutic action in the face of the countless experiences of disasters and traumatogenic crises that we have attended to in our clinical and assistance practices.
It will be important for us, as family therapists, to develop lenses with which to transgress transgenerational ecological amnesia (Morin & Kern, 2023), so as to nourish this integrative and collaborative vision in family and planetary relationships.
The ongoing disconnection between humans and the Earth fosters a pandemic dissociation because of recurrent ecological trauma. The shift towards societies in harmony with the biosphere depends on the emotional and psychological dimensions of their inhabitants, closely linked to the availability of eco-psychic energy (Villaseñor Galarza, 2017).
The turning point towards the great shift of choosing life is made up of actions in defence of the Earth, paradigmatic changes in perceptions of conative, cognitive and spiritual realities, and multiprofessional analyses of how sustainable societies are built, as Capra (2006) asserted.
All forms of life have an intrinsic right to exist, and the human population should not exceed the Earth’s carrying capacity for exploitation, Arne Naess (1989) asserted.
Ecopsychology (Pinkola, 2022) brings together ecology, which studies the environment, and psychology, which studies human beings, and works as an approach within psychology that seeks to understand psychic connections with the natural world. It is a perspective that helps us better understand ourselves and the world, recognizing that nature is not something separate from human beings; in other words, we are not independent beings. It invites us to active hope: as the practice of being and acting in the world, being peace, resilience and co-responsibility for our planetary healths. In family therapy sessions, intergenerational discussions about consumerism, waste and the misuse of oil, for example, are opportunities to co-create these reflections towards new actions.
Are we living the side effects of our evolution? Peter Russell (1991) argues that there is a crisis of perception in the deconstruction of the idea that humankind is not the centre of creation. We consume ourselves when our expectation of happiness lies in having, materially, more and more. Our children bring to family therapy sessions themes linked to loneliness and a compulsion for digital relationships. Our adolescents question and transgress the need to follow the hypocritical paths proposed for happiness, that of becoming rich and successful people in life. Anxiety, the chronic fear of suffering an environmental cataclysm, is present in these requests in the family therapy setting. Are we open, available and prepared for themes such as these, and to collaborate with planetary health?
Do gender relations and sexual freedoms achieve satisfactions of pleasure, self and other, in the relationships of our young couples and partners? When and how can middle-aged people re-plan their lives? What are the criteria for a healthy and successful life? Which places give value to caring for our older people, who are ever more numerous among the billions of beings we constitute in this present planetary world?
Planetary (Biehl & Petryna, 2014) and family healths suffer various impacts from climate change, in different geographical areas and with distinct threats to mental health (Ferreira, 2022). The scarcity of literature is probably linked to the complexity of, and intense shocks with, frightening, dynamic or high-impact phenomena. The ecosophical thinking proposed by Guattari (2022) calls on us to reconnect the knowledge of human subjectivity, of social relations and of the environment.
What value does the life of our children have, exposed as it is to the greed and corruption of the health and safety laws in force? Several communities of parents raised this question after, for example, the Kiss nightclub fire, the Brumadinho disaster (Minas Gerais), the landslides in PetrĂłpolis (Rio de Janeiro) and the school massacres of 2023 (Zampieri, 2016; 2023). Here, too, we are speaking of planetary health: the lives of young people, of children and of nature, equally under attack, are being devalued through unethical actions, in the social co-responsibilities of our planet and our people.
All of us human beings have a multifaceted self. These facets may be opaque, invisible, unused, yet ready to be activated when the nurturing surroundings allow them to emerge, Jorge Colapinto et al. (2009) assert. New terms researched in connection with the links between climate change and mental health problems include eco-anxiety, eco-guilt, ecological grief and biospheric anxieties, among others (Antonov, 2012). The effects of these climate changes, whether direct or indirect, short- or long-term, are transmitted across generations.
Since the 1970s, scientists have tried to study the effects of these climate changes in relation to the conditions of our planet and to anthropogenic activities such as the excessive use of fossil fuels, deforestation, pollution and global warming. We already face the extinction of plants and animals, reversals in predator-prey interactions, hunger, forced migration, overcrowding of coastal areas and vector-borne diseases. There is no new normal in the post-Covid-19 era, but rather the presence of the well-known normosis, the pathologization of normality, a neologism cited by Weil et al. (2014).
These themes are present in accounts of hopelessness and depression, suicidal ideation and acute stress, in the family systems we form part of in family therapy. When we care for people harmed by disasters, after the shock phase they question the point of staying alive in an environment where nature’s aggression is a fact bound to be relived. When does it stop? Bateson (1985) was already saying that as long as we treat the planet as something to be exploited, ignorantly and unconsciously, without ethical or moral considerations, we are humans who feed ecosophical crises.
Open systems, such as families, societies and planetary relationships, maintain self-regulating equilibria that evolve in complexity and benefit from deviation-amplifying feedback and constant learning. To ignore this feedback in climate change is to make possible the collapse of the planetary system, as with, for example, this disruption of the climate caused by human activity, chemical contamination, genetic alterations, waste management and the myth of unlimited progress.
To place hope in a better future, we need to make many concessions in the present, deconstruct false hopes and live the here and now, with more integrative reflection on how we are nature, across the various possible maps of love (Rinne et al., 2023).
In clinical experience, we observe various kinds of psychological and/or psychopathological suffering after disasters, floods and serious accidents. Anxiety disorders, abuse of alcohol and drugs, post-traumatic stress disorder, heightened violence in family, work and social relationships, difficult grief, vulnerabilities due to poverty, issues of gender, age, urban planning and others. Likewise, several of these forms of suffering are linked to expectations, often highly realistic ones, of foretold disasters, of repeated neglect and helplessness, and of little educational collaboration for mental health. Sometimes resigned to what they call divine punishment, some people become fixed in the ambiguity of guilt/victimization and do little to seek out their own co-responsibility in the violence against nature. Social actions patch up crises, but with little depth, in rebuilding homes in ecologically sustainable and safe places, as I have observed over the last 20 years working in humanitarian and psychological aid programmes in disasters (Zampieri, 2016).
For Pope Francis (2023), “abnormal heat, drought and other groans of the Earth are only a few palpable expressions of a silent disease that affects us all.”
How can we, as family therapists, apply ourselves to the many opportunities offered by our professional work and our action as citizens, in the devices that produce subjectivities and individual and collective resingularizations, in all these emotional, cognitive and behavioural aspects? How can we make visible the persistence of intrapersonal conflicts and loneliness in the face of planetary health, as a threatening process of deterioration? Will we combine multidisciplinary forces to share, create and promote knowledge, awareness and responsibility for a planetary mental health in which these families take the leading role? In what ways do we inspire narratives that recompose social and individual practices, collaborative in ecology?
In our experience of providing brief psychological assistance in places affected by disasters and crises, we discuss how to contextualize these proposals in each culture, family and social authority. Echoing the voices, often timid, of the most vulnerable people affected is one of the ways of inviting authorities to compassionate, concrete and ethical action. “How am I going to live without my four children, who vanished into a chasm opened by the torrent of mud?” “I chose to leave my elderly mother behind, because I had to run, with six children, from the water pouring down on us!” “I had to put my two kids on my back and tell them that the bodies of people and dogs floating in that water were dolls. What a coward I was!” “We need water, medicine, clothes, dry beds, and someone to help us have hope and faith again!”
There are voices that intersect in emotions of powerlessness and of solidarity and strength: “We are going to rebuild our town”; “When we are listened to and we listen, we are one single force!”; “I want to help build a new school to replace the one the water and mud took away!”; “I pray with the grieving mothers at the edge of what is left at the dam, so that no one else goes through abandonment like this!”; “I can survive and pursue more dreams without feeling guilty for having stayed alive!”; “Can we live somewhere the rains will not take away my people, my pets and the photographs of our life story again?”
Do we believe that we are interdependent with all planetary and cosmic life, and that all forms of life have intrinsic rights to exist? We are continually concerned with working on the various expressions of our families’ climate anxiety, with coping strategies focused on the problem, on the emotions and on the meanings that these anxieties require, as Ojala (2019) suggests. Can our clinical and educational practices increasingly facilitate the restoration of integrative visions, with ethics of care for our community networks, with the preparation of crisis and trauma teams, with reinventions of humanitarian and community leadership that care for and foster peace with suffering, with our transgenerational errors and successes, and with the deaths we live through and will live through? “The crime against humanity is not the one that involves an isolated individual, but rather the one that strikes an individual because that individual belongs to a group!” (Ojala, 2019).
Is it possible, according to Chalquist and Butell (2009), to live “enchantivism”? When we inspire deep social change in the activism of the regenerative quest of our efforts, with our families, their histories, their rites, their dreams and their connection to and presence on planet Earth, we experience deep moments of enchantment in our encounters. Thus, inspired by civility and respect, we will facilitate transmutations as deep and lasting change. Jung (2013) said that life’s problems are not solved but outgrown. Collaborative outgrowings serve and strengthen resilience.
In these reflections, as family therapists, we can become aware of being collaborators in and facilitators of a transrevolution (Estulin, 2019) for deep change in complex systems, with second-order structural transmutations, in world culture, towards just, inclusive and Earth-loving self-governance.
Start by doing what is necessary, then what is possible, and suddenly we will be doing the impossible, said Saint Francis of Assisi (thirteenth century). Where does the psyche meet Gaia?, Theodore Roszak (1995) asks us. Perhaps in biophilia and in workforces that enable us to cope with and defend against the threats of extinction to biodiversity and to mental health, which will be the opening to loving our planet. Our commitment to biophilia as the mental health of our families is a process of cosmic empathy and a search for the ecological unconscious. The poet Walt Whitman (1999), quoted by the author, urged anyone wishing to see the soul to look for it in their own form and in the beings and elements of nature.
May the traumas lived through in these times destroy neither compassion nor the deep bonds of our human/nature community. May our traumas not drive us apart from one another, and may we develop antidotes to this ecosophical crisis with humility, self-regulation of fears and a broadening of ethical values. Family therapists can be part of the chorus that builds the voice that sustains and makes possible peace in planetary health. We will create according to what we believe.
Complexe Systémique: key points
This text is an essay, almost a manifesto: it proceeds through questions and quotations rather than demonstration, and some of its references are approximate. Its strength lies elsewhere. It is a reminder that the climate crisis is not a subject outside the consulting room: it enters sessions through young people’s fear of a cataclysm, through questions about consumption, through the grief and guilt of disaster survivors. Read systemically, eco-anxiety is not first and foremost an individual symptom to be reduced, but a message about the relationships between a family, its community and its environment, often carrying a realistic concern. Three lines of work follow for therapists: welcoming these themes without psychiatrizing or sidestepping them, working with loyalties and intergenerational transmission around the relationship to nature, and linking care to local networks, where post-disaster help actually takes place. The testimonies gathered by the author show survivor guilt and collective strength coexisting after disaster. Read alongside the essay on family therapy and climate change, and the interview with Cynthia Hansen on disaster recovery.
Notes from the original
Conflict of interest. Nothing to declare.
Data availability statement. Not applicable.
Funding. Not applicable.
Acknowledgements. Not applicable.
References
Antonov, V. (2012). Ecopsicologia. Vozes.
Baker, C. (2020). Love in the age of Ecological Apocalypse. Unabridged Audiobooks.
Bateson, G. (1985). Pasos hacia una ecologia de la mente. Carlos Lohlé.
Bendell, J. (2020). Adapting deeply to likely collapse: an enhanced agenda for climate activists? Recuperado de https://jembendell.com/2020/01/15/adapting-deeply-to-likely-collapse-an-enhanced-agenda-for-climate-activists/
Biehl, J., & Petryna, A. (2014). Peopling global health. SaĂşde e Sociedade, 23(2), 376-389. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0104-12902014000200003
Capra, F. (2006). O ponto de mutação. Cultrix.
Chalquist, C., & Butell, L. (2009). Ecotherapy: healing with nature in mind. Counterpoint LLC.
Colapinto, J., Minuchin, P., Minuchin, S. (2009). Pobreza, InstituciĂłn, Familia. Amorrortu.
Cummings, E. E. (2016). Complete Poems. George J. Firmage.
Estulin, D. (2019). Transrevolução: a era da iminente desconstrução da humanidade. Vide.
Ferreira, H. G. G. (2022). Ecoansiedade, saĂşde mental e sintomas do adoecimento psĂquico: a crĂ´nica destruição da casa comum e os impactos do afastamento do sujeito humano da natureza. Revista FT, 117. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7409557
Guattari, F. (2022). As trĂŞs ecologias. Papirus.
Guterres, A. In ONU News (2023). Perspectiva global. Reportagens humanas. ONU News.
Jung, C. G. (2013). SĂmbolos da transformação. Vozes.
Lederach, J. P. (2011). A imaginação moral: ante a alma na construção da paz. Palas Athena.
Morin, E., & Kern, A. B. (2023). Terra Pátria. Sulina.
Naess, A. (1989). Ecology, community and lifestyle. Cambridge University Press.
Ojala, M. (2019). Lidando com mudanças climáticas: implicações para o bem-estar subjetivo. Departamento de Educação, Universidade de Uppsala.
Papa Francisco (2023). Exortação Apostólica Laudate Deum: a todas as pessoas de boa vontade sobre a crise climática. Paulinas.
Pinkola, P. (2022). Eco-ansiedade, tragédia e esperança: dimensões psicológicas e espirituais do clima. Journal of Religion and Science, 53(2), 545-69.
Rinne, P., Tavast, M., Glerean, E., & Sams, M. (2023). Mapas corporais de amores. Psicologia FilosĂłfica.
Roszak, T. (1995). Where Psyche Meets Gaia. In T. Roszak, M. E. Gomes & A. D. Kanner (Eds.). Ecopsychology: Restoring the Earth, healing the mind (p. 130-145). Sierra Club Books.
Russell, P. (1991). O Despertar da Terra: o cérebro global. Cultrix.
Villaseñor Galarza, A. (2017). Coração do céu, Coração da Terra: a espiritualidade na era planetária. Createspace Independent Publishing Platform.
Weil, P., Leloup, J.-Y., & Crema, R. (2014). Normose: a patologia da normalidade. Vozes.
Whitman, W. (1999). Canto de mim mesmo. Assirio e Alvim.
Zampieri, A. M. F. (2016). Los aportes teóricos de Lo Disruptivo al EMDR con damnificados de catástrofes naturales en Brasil (2008-2011). Universidad del Salvador.
Zampieri, A. M. F. (2023). Coragem, resiliência e esperança: assistência psicológica humanitária integrativa na pandemia de Covid-19. Appris.
Unofficial English translation of Apocalipse e terapia familiar: saĂşde planetária e ecopsicologia, by Ana Maria Fonseca Zampieri, Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, vol. 12, no. e0224 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.137, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe SystĂ©mique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence(lines of verse reported in indirect speech). Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.
Unofficial English translation of “Apocalipse e terapia familiar: saúde planetária e ecopsicologia”, published in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (2024) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.
Read the original articleHow to cite this article
Zampieri, A. M. F. (2024). Apocalypse and family therapy: planetary health and ecopsychology (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/apocalypse-and-family-therapy-planetary-health-and-ecopsychology (Original work published in 2024 in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, v. 12, n. e0224 (2024); republished in 2024 by Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, https://revbrasterapiafamiliar.abratef.org.br/revista/article/view/137)
To go further
Comments 0
Log in to join the discussion. Log in