AI-assisted translation

This version was translated from Portuguese by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence. In case of doubt, the original version prevails.

Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar · Case study

Conflict mediation as an aid in the treatment of serious psychiatric disorders

A 31-year-old man, addicted to cocaine and crack, with Klinefelter syndrome that no one had ever explained to his family, wants to stop but fears hospitalization. Corinna Margarete Charlotte Schabbel and Alexandre Saadeh describe how constructivist psychotherapy, psychiatric follow-up and mediation between his separated parents were combined, from 1996 to 1998, for outpatient detoxification. The case shows what mediation can open up when a family is not ready for family therapy.

Authors Corinna Margarete Charlotte Schabbel (Fielding Graduate Institute, Human and Organizational Center, Santa Barbara, California, USA) and Alexandre Saadeh (Institute of Psychiatry, Hospital das Clínicas, Faculty of Medicine, University of São Paulo, Brazil)First published Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, July 2024Translation Complexe Systémique, unofficial translation

Unofficial English translation. This article is a translation of A mediação de conflitos como auxiliar no tratamento de distúrbios psiquiátricos graves, by Corinna Margarete Charlotte Schabbel and Alexandre Saadeh, published in the Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (ABRATEF), vol. 12, no. e0424 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.134, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translated by Complexe Systémique in November 2026 with the help of artificial intelligence: the original Brazilian Portuguese text has been translated into English and reformatted, which constitutes a modification of the work under the terms of the licence. Paragraphs and headings are those of the journal; end-of-article statements are grouped in the notes; a few typographical errors in the references have been corrected silently. The abstract is the authors’ own English version. This translation was made neither by the authors nor by the journal, who are not responsible for its content or for any errors. The original version prevails.

The success achieved is due mainly to the work, which, more than interdisciplinary, was integrative and collaborative.

Corinna Margarete Charlotte Schabbel, Alexandre Saadeh

Abstract

This article demonstrates that, through a therapeutic project based on the constructivist epistemology, the joint work of the psychiatrist and psychotherapist, combined with the support of conflict mediation, is fundamental for a better understanding of how the patient’s reality was constructed, his family ties and difficulties in relationship. The professionals’ work with the patient is successful when interdisciplinary boundaries are blurred, starting to work based on the patient’s individual needs according to each moment experienced during treatment.

Keywords: Family Mediation, Constructivism, Cognitive Therapy, Drug addiction, Klinefelter Syndrome.

Introduction

The theme of this paper, the triadic relationship between psychiatrist, psychotherapist and patient and the support of family mediation within a constructivist approach, seeks to emphasize the importance of interdisciplinarity, which has been mobilizing health professionals and which adopts the basic assumption that the therapeutic encounter is co-authored and co-owned.

Looking at the history of human thought and at how it follows the historical and cultural evolution of a society, it is hard to judge which are the better or worse ways of viewing human thought, action and development. The fact is that each worldview and view of humanity, in its time, fulfilled the mission it set itself. Accordingly, as far as the view of reality is concerned, two historical periods of Western culture are decisive: modernity (from the fourteenth to the mid-twentieth century), characterized by modern science, in which there developed the use of reflective consciousness, techniques and procedures for controlling events, and the objective view of reality through an observer who holds knowledge; and postmodernity, the current phase of manifold transformations that call into question, first and foremost, the foundations of modern rationality (Brian, 1994).

Like the other sciences, psychology could not fail to be affected by the transformative crisis of postmodernity. In the encounter with concepts closer to human experience, such as historicity, cultural context (Mahoney, 1993) and the concept of self-producing systems (Maturana & Varela, 1995), the psychotherapeutic strategies of the constructivist perspective, that is, the perspective that regards human beings as the architects of their own reality, form a belief system that allows them to take their place in the world with their personal truth. We therefore now hold a view of multiple realities, constructed within a structure inherent in the organism as it interacts with its environment through language, which overturns the objective view of phenomena, or irrefutable objective truth.

The constructivist paradigm approaches the human being as a whole, that is, interacting with oneself and with the world according to lived and shared experiences. Boundaries between disciplines thus become blurred, making it possible to create a collaborative context in which specialties draw closer together, forming a space for exchange, loosening and reconstructing meanings in order to meet the demands of clinical work more effectively (Maturana, 1996).

The therapeutic model adopted avoids the idea that something needs to be fixed or put in order; the therapist takes on the role of teacher and the patient that of learner. To better explore the plurality of possibilities that allow patients to articulate the meanings they give to their life experience, which form a coherent set of representations locating them in their context, we therefore seek, in addition to a collaborative/cooperative conversation integrating therapeutic techniques borrowed from cognitive behavioral therapy, family mediation and family therapy, concrete experiences through resources borrowed from two-person psychodrama (Cukier, 1992).

Since there is no single, objective truth, what makes sense is to explore the perceptions, constructions and learning that led the patient to adopt certain patterns of organization and of interaction with the environment. In this way, the individual, here the patient, is, throughout the therapeutic process, a co-author of that process, and not a mere recipient of information.

Case history

F, single, 31 years old, addicted to cocaine, both powder and crack, and with Klinefelter syndrome (XXY), lives with his mother (73); his parents have been separated for five years. His father (59) is still the family’s mainstay and provider, although he remarried as soon as he left home. F has an older brother (35), with whom he has a superficial relationship. When he began treatment, F had been engaged for two years. He married at the end of the treatment.

F was always a rebellious child, with learning difficulties and poor school performance, and the school requested psychological follow-up. After a psychodiagnostic assessment, F had play therapy for three years. At puberty, he was very troubled by his sudden growth, having always been the tallest in his class, and by the development of breasts. He underwent a mastectomy in 1979, when a karyotype was ordered and Klinefelter syndrome was diagnosed. It should be mentioned that the meaning of the syndrome was never clear to the family. At 18, F began using large amounts of marijuana, which he swapped for cocaine at 21, moving on to crack, encouraged by his drug-using friends and by a chronic lack of money. He kept using marijuana to be able to fall asleep after using cocaine.

He completed two years of a business administration degree, although he never took his studies very seriously: “I always took exams stoned, even the university entrance exam.” He never held a job for long: administrative services intern (nine months); office assistant (three months); stockroom assistant (four months); stock clerk (three months); chemical products salesman (two months); messenger (one year); among others. The reason for leaving was always connected with drugs, aggression, fights and frequent absences.

F sought treatment in January 1996, as he had been unemployed for over a year and his fiancée had given him an ultimatum, since he was spending all the couple’s savings on drugs.

At our first meeting, which he attended with his fiancée, his speech was disjointed and confused, mixing reality and fantasy. Some important information was provided by the fiancée. Although F was frightened by the threat of the engagement being broken off, he was still using crack every day and said he was facing a dilemma, because both his fiancée and crack were important in his life, as he had never had anyone by his side. He wanted to be admitted to hospital, but he was afraid of hospitalization, having had some very unpleasant experiences in childhood and adolescence; on the other hand, he did not feel strong enough to give up the drug. I suggested that, during the weeks of vacation the couple had planned, he try to cut down his drug use and record it on the drug-use monitoring sheet.

The purpose of this monitoring sheet is to teach the patient to identify the automatic or dysfunctional thoughts that coexist with the thoughts urging him to keep using the substance (craving). By writing down on the sheet what drives him to use the drug, he is in fact preparing himself to:

  • perceive the dysfunctional thoughts that are repetitive and negative;
  • see how far these thoughts influence the subsequent emotional, behavioral and physiological responses;
  • create the conditions to cross-check these thoughts against his actions and thus, by perceiving the psychological dysfunction that drives him towards drug dependence, begin a process of re-signifying his beliefs.

By using a strategy that depends on his own will, perceiving and writing down what is happening to him, he identifies the dysfunctional thoughts that compromise his interaction with others and that, being distressing, interfere with the possibility of reaching new goals. The monitoring sheets, filled in by the patient, serve to recognize, control or change his own behavior and to use alternative responses to reach the goals worked out together with the therapist (Beck, 1995).

Through the perception of dysfunctional thoughts and the identification of negative beliefs, a positive change takes place which, in this case, can be divided into three distinct stages: the first is based on raising awareness for detoxification; the second concerns the period of abstinence; and the third is the maintenance phase.

Although the patient was quite motivated to give up the drug, mainly because of his fiancée’s demand and his fear of losing her, it was immensely difficult for him to keep away from his peers, which left him extremely anxious, with bouts of tachycardia, excessive sweating, rushed and stumbling speech, and aggressiveness towards the other family members, who regarded him as maladjusted, lazy and arrogant.

Once the patient accepted that he would not manage to go through detoxification with psychological support alone (he did not at first accept a doctor’s involvement), psychiatric follow-up was recommended to him. Communication between the parents and their son was at that point practically non-existent. It was suggested that, before he was referred to the psychiatrist, they should all take part in a mediation process, with the aims of opening up a possibility of talking about the matter and of involving his parents in the treatment, in paying for it and in the support their son would need after treatment, given that he was entirely financially dependent on both of them, and also of providing a place to talk about the troubled, disorganized and feelingless relationships between them.

The second phase, abstinence proper, was characterized by reduced general arousal, lower motivation and a diminished capacity to feel pleasure. The memory of the negative effects of crack gradually faded, and the craving grew, especially when the patient came into contact with the places or people that had prompted him to use the drug in the past. F showed depressive symptoms, compulsive eating and sexual impotence, which gradually decreased. As the unpleasant symptoms subsided, F felt motivated, above all because he had recovered his family ties, as shown in the last of the three mediation sessions.

At a difficult stage, when the only support was the mother’s understanding and the importance of her presence in her son’s daily life, the effects of the inhaled crack rock, which the patient had nicknamed “tuim”, appeared in his dreams, and there were three relapses, which caused:

  • euphoria with perceptual changes, a sharper perception of sensations and environmental stimuli;
  • increased self-esteem, through accepting the fact that he had always been different from his peers without knowing why;
  • a marked increase in libido and in masturbation, which occurs throughout the period of euphoria and leads him to smoke another rock straight away to prolong the feeling of pleasure;
  • decreased appetite;
  • an increased tendency towards physical aggression and psychomotor agitation.

The craving was weaker and came at increasingly longer intervals; the depressive symptoms had practically disappeared; and his motivation to stay “clean” had risen considerably since he found work (February 1997). He married in November 1997, which helped normalize his sex life, although he went through some periods of craving, which were managed with medication and a return to psychotherapy, whose sessions had been spaced out after January 1998.

Analysis and discussion

Cocaine, acting on the brain, brings about changes in the psyche, and the abuse practised by F for years on end, with very short periods of abstinence but without ever giving up marijuana since the age of 18, gives us the characteristic of a continuum, that is, a progressive escalation in levels of use, starting with marijuana, moving on to snorted cocaine and culminating in crack, this last stage, eight months long, being marked by peaks of heavy compulsive use, up to 12 rocks a day, interspersed with two or three days of lower crack use combined with marijuana to sleep.

From the analysis of both the daily activity record and the drug-use monitoring sheet, we were able to infer that F alternates between marijuana and cocaine, and that the motivation to use is always accompanied by intense anxiety and by compulsive and/or phobic features, sensory and perceptual disorders, auditory hallucinations and psychotic delusions of persecution.

Before the treatment proper began, mediation was introduced, at F’s request, to bring about a rapprochement between his parents (who had been separated for some years) and to resume the interrupted relationship. It was crucial to negotiate an agreement on the importance of emotional and financial support for the treatment to have any chance of success, taking particular account of the father, who, since F lost his last job, had not only withdrawn from contact with his son but had also withdrawn his financial support.

Six mediation sessions were held, two with the couple, two with the father and two with the mother, with the aim not only of achieving a cooperative relationship in which the existing disagreements between the couple, still unresolved even though they had been separated for years, could be clarified, but also of having them resume their roles as father and mother for the benefit of their son’s treatment. The mediation took the following points into account:

  • getting the parents to talk about Klinefelter syndrome without old grudges once again becoming the subject of endless arguments;
  • seeking the commitment of both to the treatment and their acceptance of their son’s drug dependence;
  • reaching a financial agreement for the treatment (medical and psychological fees, medication, the patient’s personal expenses, etc.);
  • establishing an agreement for the parents to cooperate as active helpers in the treatment, setting up a period of truce, since the two of them were hardly speaking to each other.

The renegotiation of the father’s and the mother’s relationships with their son took place during the mediation sessions, because after the couple separated, the patient’s lack of discipline, his comings and goings between jobs, his lack of any schedule, etc., had become a recurring topic between them. Although he was already an adult when his parents finally separated, the patient had always behaved towards them in an immature, aggressive, erratic and defiant way.

Once the mutual cooperation agreement had been made and the financial details settled, the continuation of the treatment was made conditional on the following:

  • the father would bear the costs of the treatment for six months, a period he considered appropriate for his son to “show” his willingness and effort to change the course of his own life;
  • the maintenance allowance was adjusted so that the patient could stay at home, without working, for a period of six months;
  • the mother would take on the role of helper in the therapy, and could count on the father’s collaboration whenever necessary;
  • father and son would meet again at least once a week for a joint activity. The father would also accompany his son to the psychiatrist;
  • should hospitalization become necessary, the parents agreed to accept it and to bear the costs without threatening their son with the sale of the property that had been given to him when he turned 21;
  • once the six months were up, an evaluation would be made regarding the continuation of the treatment.

F sought psychiatric help in July 1996, six months after the start of psychotherapy. In all, three consultations were held. He came to the first one with his father. After the anamnesis and guidance for the patient, the father was brought into the consultation, with a view to guiding him as well. This first contact was productive, the thinking being that father and son should speak to each other with greater maturity and frankness. Pharmacological therapy was started and tests were ordered.

At his first follow-up visit, F appeared more energetic, drug free and euphoric about his success. The test results were normal. His mother, who came with him, was hopeful about the treatment.

At the third consultation, F was depressed, as he had gone back to using crack. The pharmacological treatment was changed and proceeded slowly, with difficulties and relapses brought on by craving, as well as insomnia and emotional disturbances.

Before continuing with the discussion, it should be noted that the patient has a genetic syndrome (Klinefelter syndrome). Every cell in the body has 46 chromosomes, which are identical in pairs; that is, there are 23 pairs of chromosomes, of which 22 are autosomes and are similar in men and women, and one pair is the sex chromosomes, designated by letters: women have two X chromosomes, and men one X and one Y. The karyotype of a normal man is therefore represented as 46, XY (Cruz, Furtado, Silva & Carvalho, 2019).

Klinefelter syndrome is caused by a sex chromosome aneuploidy. In more than 80% of cases the karyotype is 47, XXY. Because of the presence of two X chromosomes, patients with Klinefelter syndrome and a 47 XXY karyotype are sex chromatin positive, with an incidence similar to that found in normal women.

In about two thirds of cases, the event that gave rise to the syndrome, nondisjunction, occurred in maternal meiosis. The remaining third arose in paternal meiosis. In the former, the mean maternal age is increased. Klinefelter syndrome is therefore a genetic disorder that affects only the male population, occurring in one in every thousand births.

The patient in question has the 47, XXY karyotype and, during his development (according to his mother’s account), presented the following symptoms, considered typical of the syndrome:

  • Physical: at birth, his appearance was normal, with weight and length in line with the expected average. From his fourth year onwards, he showed a tendency to grow (in height) that set him apart from his age group. Puberty was late. Chest development was poor. Growth of the penis and testes can be considered normal. There was abnormal breast development, for which F underwent corrective surgery. The patient is sterile, according to a confirmatory laboratory test carried out in December 1996. His libido was low at puberty and is currently fluctuating;
  • Psychological: he showed delayed language development and problems with the perceptual process (writing, reading, speaking). His comprehension, when helped by the use of appropriate vocabulary, can be considered within the normal range. F did not develop at the same pace as his peers and showed a tendency to withdraw and keep away from the group in preadolescence and adolescence. During this same period, learning difficulties, aggressive behavior towards his peers and mood swings were observed.

At the school’s request, the patient was referred at the age of 11 for a psychodiagnostic assessment and, later, for play therapy.

Klinefelter syndrome may also occur in mosaic form (47 XXY, 48 XXXY). Variants of the syndrome, identified in karyotypes, may be associated with oligophrenia; that is, the presence of an additional X chromosome lowers the intelligence quotient (IQ) by 16 points. The psychometric tests carried out in childhood do not place the necessary emphasis on detecting discrepancies between verbal ability and performance intelligence, leaving room for partial interpretations. It is common for patients with chromosomal abnormalities to present learning difficulties and specific behavioral disorders. Research comparing the quality of communication between individuals with IQs in the normal range and those with more severe chromosomal abnormalities has found that there is a delay in the language development of people with such abnormalities that is directly proportional to the severity of the abnormality found (Ong & Robertson, 1995).

The poverty observed in sentence construction and the limitations in verbal discourse, as well as learning difficulties, show high scores in people with Klinefelter syndrome.

The patient’s behaviors, such as blaming others, lying, feelings of abandonment alternating with feelings of grandiosity and arrogance, conveyed through stereotyped and at times halting speech, or refusing to answer without first asking a string of questions only to end up with an evasion or trivialities, show, as far as cognitive development is concerned, an oscillation between childhood and adolescence. He has difficulty concentrating on reading and understanding what he reads. He does not like writing.

The karyotype was ordered at the time of the breast surgery (August 1979). For unknown reasons, neither the meaning nor the scope of the syndrome was ever explained to the parents.

The patient and his family were told how important it was for him to be followed by an endocrinologist for testosterone replacement. Because the syndrome was discovered late, testosterone levels had to be supplemented, since testosterone is not produced at the necessary levels in 47, XXY patients, as is the case with F. The hormones, initially given intramuscularly every 30 days, were later, after assessment, administered through the skin (patches). Maintaining testosterone levels is important to prevent, among other symptoms, the breasts from reappearing.

Hypotheses and working strategies

In light of what has been reported so far, the following hypotheses and strategies for working with the patient were arrived at:

  • through recognizing drug addiction as a personal pattern for fitting into the family context, the parents, although already separated, were able to see how far family practices and patterns (addictive behaviors, lack of expression of feelings in family relationships, the father’s constant absence, gambling and other household addictions) had served as a model for their son, who, unable to bear reality, opted for drugs;
  • the mother/son dyad, with its extremely infantilized and double-binding features, turned drug addiction into a pseudo-individuation;
  • the fiancée, in whose family of origin alcoholism recurs across generations, colluded with the patient’s drug addiction until it became socially unacceptable, at which point she broke off the alliance, unsettling the patient and leading him to seek treatment;
  • cocaine use gave the patient feelings of power and omnipotence he had never experienced before, giving him opportunities to distance himself from his family;
  • the drug was always tinged with eroticism, and the patient always spoke of it as if it were a lover;
  • the family life cycle had stalled at the patient’s adolescence, so that only strategies aimed at a family with an adolescent child, and not with a 30-year-old adult, would work;
  • the symptoms were being fed by the system. Paradoxical tasks were therefore used to change repetitive sequences of behavior, which culminated in increasingly long periods of abstinence;
  • the couple, separated and finding it hard to talk to each other, would also be given tasks aimed at bringing them closer together for the benefit of their son’s treatment, which brought about a change in communication and in the interrelationship of the triad, which is now friendly and cooperative;
  • a very positive relationship was maintained throughout with the family and with the patient, which considerably reduced the mother’s guilt (caused more by the syndrome than by the drug addiction) and the father’s defensive stance (distrustful and doubtful about the success of the treatment);
  • with the father, a complicity was sought with a view to his son’s social reintegration. This ended up bringing the two closer together and changing the original bond;
  • the mother was asked to act as an observer during the most critical period and was given some specific tasks, such as managing and keeping track of her son’s schedule, money and activities during the detoxification period. As a result, the home environment stabilized.

Therapeutic approach

Constructivist epistemology rests on the assertion that individuals, by virtue of their structure or biology, are victims not of reality but of the construction made of that reality. That is, from a constructivist perspective, the therapeutic process does not differ much from any other human process of inquiry and learning. It is an active procedure for developing more viable and satisfying ways of being in the world, according to the moment experienced in interaction with the environment (Ferreira & Abreu, 1998).

On the assumption that the initial social nucleus, the family, represents the individual’s first relationships, which will give rise to his or her first constructions, the family brings about not only the acquisition of behavior patterns but is also responsible for the functional construction of a socially and historically contextualized model, expressed through the communication system the family establishes to maintain family homeostasis, such as family myths, mandates (functional missions each member receives, that is, orders handed down through the generations), prophecies, patterns of repetition and communication patterns.

In this sense, individual construction follows social and family rules. That is, within one’s personal structure, some family patterns persist, but with a personal stamp. Family functioning, in the long run, depends on the family’s capacity to adapt. Through the stages of the life cycle, the family needs to change its relational patterns in order to overcome crises, and this does not always happen. Because of the difficulty of restoring balance when the children “adolesce”, families tend, as in the present case, to freeze in an earlier phase, more comfortable because it is familiar (Schabbel, 2005, 2020).

Children, in their first years of life, make this choice: that of creating a reality of their own. Recalling Piaget (1963), who says that children have their own logic of thinking, which is not necessarily adult logic, in this individual process, within the limits of their own development, children already display highly distinctive features in the way they act. Thus begins a process of identity construction which is transformed with each new experience and exchange with the environment.

Adolescence represents a significant change and, as individuals go on living, they interweave their experiences with the image they have of themselves. As long as this image produces more positive than negative results, they keep it.

Adolescence returns individuals, for a short period, to Piaget’s (1963) preoperational stage, an emotionally egocentric period: only what the SELF feels matters; they cannot see the other’s feelings, nor put themselves in the other’s place and perceive feelings. Only they are right, and if the other disagrees, the other is wrong. There is a constant need to experience things, because only then do things have value. Concrete experience is what counts, even though rationally they are already able to use abstract logic (Vermersch, 1979, 1999).

The resulting idea is that the emotional process moves at a much slower pace than the rational one. The stages of emotional development proceed much more slowly, and, unfortunately, little is done in our culture for the emotional and the rational to develop concurrently and in association, thereby enabling the maturation of the individual as a whole (Schabbel, 2020).

In adolescence, still under strong social pressure (such as family and friends), individuals go through a process of review, seeking to know, in the here and now, who they are and what they want from their lives. It is the moment to redefine oneself as a person. In this self-redefinition, they are subject to both external and internal influences; there are both emotional and social pressures to be handled and brought to a good conclusion (Zoja, 2000).

This reconstruction of oneself may last from a few years to the rest of one’s life, and the fluidity and continuity of the creative and symbolic process of constructing alternative meanings for the situations that arise, for new challenges and new phases of the life cycle, depend on how one deals with the situations that arise in each present moment.

When the reappraisal, the redefinition of oneself, takes place progressively, in a creative flow, individuals make their choices believing in all their consequences and taking them on. It is the full integration of the SELF, in a constant search for happiness, in which what matters, what one truly values, is BEING, broadening one’s understanding of the other’s dynamics and making it possible to make choices about living together.

In this process there is no passive acceptance of facts, but rather active understanding and taking responsibility for one’s own attitudes. Nor is there tantrum for tantrum’s sake, or no for the sake of no. There is an understanding of facts and an owning of one’s attitudes. The balancing process begun in childhood continues; there is an inner questioning of one’s own action that frees one from egocentrism, increases the capacity for abstraction, enriches inner language and the possibility of dealing with one’s own memories, which, being structural, may bring back situations and feelings that are not always pleasant to remember. Emotional memories are the ones that most foster maturation, when related to the other capacities, since simply remembering and bringing facts to the surface without relating them leads nowhere. It would merely be a pain whose existence is not always worth remembering.

From our first contact with the patient and his difficulties, described above, we realized that the only way to reach him and his pain was to be with him so that we could travel together, on a teleonomic journey (from the Greek telos and nomos, legitimate end), in a direction of development neither predetermined nor random, yet including intentions and purposes. The therapeutic dyad is available both to be guided and to guide, depending on the moment, always ready to attend to the patient’s inner time, opening up spaces as he is willing, living through his most intimate dramas alongside him without placing itself in an asymmetrical position, instead proposing alternatives for the reconstruction of rigid and stereotyped meanings and seeking a new balance, always grounded in the concrete, using narrative, dramatic and playful resources.

In the initial sensitization phase, we made ourselves available to the patient and his family, both at the office and by telephone, 24 hours a day, which was important and extremely valuable at some crucial moments.

During the detoxification process, in addition to pharmacotherapy, tools from cognitive behavioral therapy were combined, such as the drug-use monitoring sheet, whose purpose is to help the patient recognize his own structures and schemas and the responses they provoke.

It is important to stress that through self-monitoring the patient becomes the director of his own actions and wishes. He becomes an observer of himself, and the therapist takes on the role of facilitator in building strategies that foster change. To reinforce successful situations, a report of successful strategies was introduced, since the act of concentrating on writing about a successful experience gave the patient a certain confidence and awareness of situational stimuli, possibly associated with the problem response, which was discussed during the sessions, enabling him to identify emotional responses, especially anxiety.

Throughout the treatment, self-recording was maintained, serving both as a device for assessing the progress of the process and as an instrument of positive reinforcement, since its rewarding character increased self-control efforts in difficult situations, making it possible to sense the “arrival” of a crisis and reducing “failures”.

For greater therapeutic effectiveness, a record of daily activities was chosen. Because of the difficulty in writing the self-record, it was divided into stages, which were always discussed with the patient during the sessions:

  • a record of daily activities replacing the drug-use monitoring record, at first with the help of an available family member, his mother, and later on his own;
  • introduction of a daily schedule with set times for various activities (time to get up, shower, meals and activities);
  • setting future goals on the basis of the difficulties noted in the records and experienced in the dramatic “as if” space.

To get around the refusal of hospitalization, we used procedures drawn from the home detoxification and social rehabilitation process proposed by Stanton (1991), which involves three or more individuals: the addict and the parents or their substitutes, who form an intimate, interdependent and interpersonal system. When the balance of the system in question is threatened, the dependent person springs into action and creates a dramatic situation that focuses attention on him or her; according to the family structure and plot, the dependent person’s functions are to protect and preserve the family’s homeostatic balance, at the cost of a standstill in the addict’s developmental process.

The constructivist approach and, above all, the recognition of the difficulties of the patient, who has a genetic syndrome that isolates him socially, stalled in his development at the adolescent stage, combined with work on family integration, were the pillars that made it possible to carry the therapeutic process forward.

However, the success achieved is due mainly to the work, which, more than interdisciplinary, was integrative and collaborative, and the medication acted as a necessary adjunct to get through the critical phases of stress caused by the withdrawal crisis. The ease of contact and the trust between psychotherapist and psychiatrist, and the conflict mediation techniques used to bring the parents back together to care for their only son [F does, however, have an older brother, mentioned above. — Editor’s note.], allowed a broader view of the case, making room not only for the patient’s recovery but also for the restoration of the family’s fragile bonds, restarting the development of the life cycle and the affection between them.

This case made it possible for other drug-dependent patients to be treated as outpatients, opening up new possibilities for restoring family relationships. The mediation of old conflicts that are part of families’ daily lives, and that contribute to the worsening of drug addiction cases, greatly helped the process, since the family was not willing, at that time, to undergo family therapy.

Complexe Systémique: key points

This case report, drawn from a course of treatment in the 1990s, is valuable above all for its set-up: even before the psychiatric referral, mediation reconnects two separated parents who were no longer speaking, sets an agreement on money, presence and limits, and turns both father and mother into allies of detoxification. When a family refuses family therapy, mediation can thus offer a less threatening way in. The systemic reading is explicit: a symptom that protects the family’s balance (Stanton), a life cycle frozen at adolescence, a double-binding mother-son relationship, paradoxical tasks. Some caution is needed, however. The success is not backed by any measure; the number of mediation sessions varies from one passage to another (three or six); the article does not say who conducted the mediation or how it fitted with the psychotherapy; and the genetics section, with its dated vocabulary (“oligophrenia”, “normal man”) and unsourced figures, risks reducing F’s difficulties to his karyotype. One question remains useful in sessions: what is the symptom for, in a family where no one speaks to anyone any more? Read alongside the article on addictive disorder as a search for coherence, and Maurizio Coletti’s account of the relational treatment of drug addiction.

Notes from the original

Conflict of interest. Nothing to declare.

Contributions. Substantive scientific and intellectual contributions to the study: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh; conception and design: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh; data analysis and interpretation: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh; writing of the article: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh; critical review: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh; final approval: C. M. C. Schabbel and A. Saadeh.

Data availability statement. Not applicable.

Funding. Not applicable.

Acknowledgements. Not applicable.

References

Beck, J. (1995). Terapia cognitiva: teoria e prática. Artes Médicas.

Brian, G. (1994). How the leopard changed its spots: the evolution of complexity. Touchstone.

Cruz, M. L. C. M., Furtado, A. C., Silva, C. G. R., & Carvalho, F. A. (2019). Síndromes e psicologia: atuação, prática e pesquisa. Juruá.

Cukier, R. (1992). Psicodrama Bi-Pessoal. Ágora.

Ferreira, R. F., & Abreu, C. N. (1998). Psicoterapia e construtivismo: considerações teóricas e práticas. Artmed.

Mahoney, M. J. (1993). Introduction to Special Section: Theoretical developments in the cognitive psychotherapies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 61(2), 187-193. https://doi.org/10.1037//0022-006x.61.2.187

Maturana, H. (1996). A ontologia da realidade. Editora UFMG.

Maturana, H., & Varela, F. (1995). A árvore do conhecimento: as bases biológicas do conhecimento humano. Psy.

Ong, S. H., & Robertson, J. R. (1995). Schizophrenia with karyotype mosaic 47, XXY/48, XXY+ 8. Psychiatric Genetics, 5(2), 67-69. https://doi.org/10.1097/00041444-199522000-00004

Piaget, J. (1963). A construção do real na criança. Zahar.

Schabbel, C. (2005). Relações familiares na separação conjugal: contribuições da mediação. Psicologia: Teoria e Prática, 7(1), 13-20.

Schabbel, C. (2020). Mediação na prática: abordagem circular-narrativa. Longarina.

Stanton, D. (1991). Terapia familiar del abuso y adicción a las drogas. Paidós.

Vermersch, P. V. (1979). Peut-On Utiliser Les Données De La Psychologie Génétique Pour Analyser Le Fonctionnement Cognitif Des adultes. Cahiers de Psychologie, 22(1-2), 59-74.

Vermersch, P. V. (1999). Introspection As Practiced. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 6(2-3), 17-42.

Zoja, L. (2000). História da arrogância: psicologia e limites do desenvolvimento humano. Axis Mundi.

Unofficial English translation of A mediação de conflitos como auxiliar no tratamento de distúrbios psiquiátricos graves, by Corinna Margarete Charlotte Schabbel and Alexandre Saadeh, Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, vol. 12, no. e0424 (2024), doi: 10.60114/rbtf.v12i1.134, under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Translation (with the help of artificial intelligence) and layout: Complexe Systémique, November 2026 — the work has been modified under the terms of the licence. Neither the authors nor the journal are responsible for this translation; the original version prevails.

Unofficial English translation of “A mediação de conflitos como auxiliar no tratamento de distúrbios psiquiátricos graves”, published in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar (2024) under a CC BY 4.0 licence. Made by Complexe Systémique with the help of artificial intelligence, it does not come from the authors or the journal, who are not responsible for its content; the original version prevails.

Read the original article

How to cite this article

Schabbel, C. M. C., et Saadeh, A. (2024). Conflict mediation as an aid in the treatment of serious psychiatric disorders (Complexe Systémique, Trans.). Complexe Systémique. https://app.complexe-systemique.com/en_GB/articles/conflict-mediation-as-an-aid-in-the-treatment-of-serious-psychiatric-disorders (Original work published in 2024 in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, v. 12, n. e0424 (2024); republished in 2024 by Revista Brasileira de Terapia Familiar, https://revbrasterapiafamiliar.abratef.org.br/revista/article/view/134)

To go further

Discussion

Comments 0

Log in to join the discussion. Log in

  1. No comment yet. Start the discussion.

Cart

Your cart is empty.